V6 - Argumentative Essay Lesson Series

Essay writing

English language and literature – VWO6 2023/2024

L. de Jager, R. de Graaf, T. Wiering, F. de Voijs, S. Lindenburg

1 / 80
next
Slide 1: Slide
New lesson editor

This lesson contains 80 slides, with text slides.

Report this lesson

Items in this lesson

Essay writing

English language and literature – VWO6 2023/2024

L. de Jager, R. de Graaf, T. Wiering, F. de Voijs, S. Lindenburg

Program

  • Lesson 1: Explaining test & topics

  • Lesson 2: Writing an essay outline, finding sources, & writing an introduction

  • Lesson 3: Writing two body paragraphs defending your argument

  • Lesson 4: Writing a rebuttal/refutation & conclusion

  • Lesson 5: Re-writing your essay


Lesson aims

  • By the end of the lesson series, you can…

    • Write a proper argumentative essay

    • Write a solid thesis statement

    • Find and use sources to back up your statements

    • Defend your own statement by means of solid arguments, explanation and illustration

    • Find a counter argument to your statement and write a rebuttal to strengthen your own argument

    • Write a conclusive paragraph

    • Use in-text citation and create a works cited list in APA style



Lesson 1:
Topic explanation

  • Lesson aims

    • You know what the final product is

    • You know what an argumentative essay is

    • You know what to do to write an argumentative essay

    • You know the essay’s structure

    • You have seen both good and bad examples of an argumentative essay


Argumentative essay

  • Persuasive

  • Shows your arguments in favor of a (controversial) debate

  • Shows your understanding of this topic

  • Shows convincing evidence in order to persuade reader

  • Shows that you are aware of possible counter arguments

Essay writing

An argumentative essay consists of the following parts:

Introduction;

Three body paragraphs, one argument per paragraph;

2 pro

1 con (refutation)

Conclusion.


600-1000 words

Introduction

Attract reader’s attention if possible;

Scene setting;

Thesis statement;

Short mention of arguments in favor of thesis statement, in different wording than in the rest of your essay!

Body paragraph (3x)

SEXI

Statement = Topic sentence (first and most important sentence)

your argument in favor of statement

Explanation = Evidence for argument.

Illustration = Examples

Body paragraph 3 = opponents’ argument/counter argument (=refutation)

Body paragraph (3x)

TEXAS

Topic Sentence – your argument

Explain your argument

Example/evidence -- What is your source?

Analysis – How does your evidence and examples explain your argument

Summary – So?

Body paragraph 3 = opponents’ argument/counter argument (=refutation)

Conclusion

Short repetition of three arguments from body paragraphs in different wording than rest of essay;

Concluding statement, in different wording than the introduction.

Suggestion for future action

Works cited

  • APA

  • In-text citation (Johnson, 2021)

  • Works cited

    • End of essay

    • Alphabetical order

    • You can use a source generator



General Tips & Tricks

  • Stay formal

  • No contractions

  • No abbreviations

  • Avoid personal pronouns

  • Use passive voice

  • Use indirect speech

  • No questions

  • No announcements

  • Use linking words (signal words and function words!)


Example essays

  • Discuss the examples in groups of two (±8min)

  • Rate them from 1 (good) to 3 (bad)

    • Make sure you can explain why!

Common mistakes

  • Possession (using the apostrophe):

    • It is comparable with being born and learning your own country its language.

    • Besides that, it makes it easier for exchange students to adapt in a country its environment.


Example topic

assignment

What do you think? Is the legislation of quotas the right approach to create gender equality on corporate boards? Is gender equality on corporate boards desirable at all? Make up your mind on whether you are pro or con and create a statement.


Persuasive essay

  • Argumentative essay about a pre-determined topic

  • 600-1000 words

  • Create own opinion and think of arguments in favor as well as against your statement

  • Use provided sources

End of lesson 1:
topic explanation

  • You know what an argumentative essay is

    • You know what to do to write an argumentative essay

    • You know the essay’s structure

    • You know what to do during the first weeks after the Christmas break


  • Homework for mock essay:

    • Find a topic you want to write about

      • Find some sources


  • Next lesson:

    • Write an outline to your essay

      • Find more sources

      • Start thinking about your viewpoints


Lesson 2:
Writing an outline, Thesis statement & introduction

  • Lesson aims

    • You know the topic for the mock essay

    • You have created your viewpoints on the topic

    • You can write an outline

    • You know what an introduction consists of

    • You can create a thesis statement

    • You can write the introduction to your essay



Example topic

Create an outline: step 1

Answer and write down the following questions:

  1. What is your opinion? Are you for or against?

  2. What arguments can you think of in favor of your viewpoint?

  3. What arguments can you think of against your viewpoint?


Example 1 outline: step 1

Companies should have minimum quotas of women on company boards

  1. What is your opinion? Are you for or against?
    I am for this argument.

  2. What arguments can you think of in favor of your viewpoint?
    More women in higher positions which will result in more equality in the work force.

  3. What arguments can you think of against your viewpoint?
    It is slightly discriminatory and can easily be misused.


Example 2 outline: step 1

Black Pete should be abolished

  1. What is your opinion? Are you for or against?
    I am for this argument

  2. What arguments can you think of in favor of your viewpoint?
    Black Pete is Racist & Children do not care what St. Nicholas’ helper looks like

  3. What arguments can you think of against your viewpoint?
    It is an age-old tradition


Example outline: step 2

  1. Find background information online

  2. Find information to back up your arguments

  • Use formal and scientific sources using scholars.google.com

    • Stay formal and polite


Example topic

Create an outline: step 3

Create a grid writing down which information you are going to put where.



Example outline

Opinion/Thesis statement: Black Pete should be abolished

  • Intro: Scene setting and explanation on Black Pete
    History, Slavery, Tradition

  • BP1: Black Pete is racist
    Spitting image of an African slave during the European imperialism + Offending

  • BP2: Children do not care what St. Nicholas’ helper looks like
    Presents + debate is solely between adults + different colors

  • BP3: Tradition
    No reason racism can be allowed + tradition was shaped hundreds of years ago

Assignment

  • Create an essay outline for your chosen topic.


Effective Thesis statement

  1. Clearly communicates your essay’s main idea

  • Topic

    • Suggest what you will say

      • Purpose

  1. More than a general subject, a statement of fact, or an announcement of your intent

  2. Carefully worded

  • One sentence

    • Direct/straightforward (no abstract language, no complex terminology, or unnecessary details)

      • Do not include phrases such as “personally, I believe, I hope to demonstrate, it seems to me, etc.”

  1. Suggest essay’s direction, emphasis and scope

  • Don’t make promises you cannot fulfil

Thesis statement

exercise

Have a look at the following thesis statements. Write down what’s wrong with them and improve them.

  1. In this essay, I will examine the environmental effects of residential and commercial development on the coastal regions of the United States.

  2. Residential and commercial development in the coastal regions of the United states.

  3. How to avoid coastal overdevelopment.

  4. Coastal Development: Pro and Con.

  5. Residential and commercial development of America’s coastal regions benefits some people, but it has a number of disadvantages.

  6. The environmentalists’ position on coastal development.

  7. More and more coastal regions in the United States are being overdeveloped.

  8. Residential and commercial development guidelines need to be developed for coastal regions of the United States.

  9. Coastal development is causing beach erosion.

  10. At one time I enjoyed walking on the beach, but commercial and residential development ruined the experience for me.


Introduction

Attract reader’s attention if possible;

Scene setting;

Thesis statement;

Short mention of arguments in favor of thesis statement, in different wording than in the rest of your essay!

Example introduction

  • “Eat a banana, black monkey.” These words were hurled at African-American director Roger Ross Williams when he announced his documentary called ‘Blackface’ (CNN, 2015). In a world that is becoming increasingly tolerant and emancipated, racism is still a big problem. Although people do not often bring it up, it can still be seen and heard in our daily lives. One of the ways in which racism is still widely expressed is the Dutch tradition of ‘Zwarte Piet’, who is the loyal companion of St. Nicholas, the Dutch equivalent of Santa Claus. ‘Zwarte Piet’, or ‘Black Pete’, is a servant who bears a striking resemblance to African slaves from the past. Although ‘Zwarte Piet’ is one of the oldest Dutch traditions, it should be banned because it is incredibly racist, and children do not care about their looks.


Assignment

  • Write or rewrite a thesis statement for your topic

  • Write an introduction to your essay finishing with your thesis statement.



End of Lesson 2:
introduction & thesis statement

  • You know the topic for the draft version

  • You have created your viewpoints on the topic

  • You can write an outline

  • You know what an introduction consists of

  • You can create a thesis statement

  • You can write the introduction to your mock essay


  • Homework

    • Finish the introduction to your mock essay


  • Next lesson

    • Writing body paragraphs


Lesson 3:
writing a body paragraph

  • Lesson aims

    • You know how to write a body paragraph

    • You know what a body paragraph consists of

    • You know what a topic sentence is

    • You know how to write a topic sentence

    • You know how to make references




Body paragraph

  • Criteria

    • Topic sentence

    • Evidence based on sources

    • Conclusion

    • Coherence


  • SEXI

    • Statement = Topic sentence (first and most important sentence)

      • your argument in favor of statement

    • Explanation = Evidence for argument.

    • Illustration = Examples


BP: Topic sentence

  • = kernzin

  • Supports thesis statement

  • First sentence of paragraph

  • Smoothly connected to previous paragraph

  • Contains the key point of this paragraph (which is your argument)

  • Backbone

  • Guides both author as well as reader

  • Highlight in yellow!


Effective topic sentence:

  1. State your main idea clearly

  2. Balance the topic sentence between specifics andgeneral ideas

  3. Hook the reader

  4. Keep it short

  5. Give a reasonable opinion

  6. Use the topic sentence as a transition


example

Thesis statement = Although ‘Zwarte Piet’ is one of the oldest Dutch traditions, it should be banned because it is incredibly racist and children do not care about their looks.


Topic sentence 1 = Firstly, and quite obviously, ‘Zwarte Piet’ is just plain racist.

Topic sentence 2 = Secondly, children do not care what St. Nicholas’ helper looks like, as long as they get their presents.


Write a topic sentence

  • ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________Woodpeckers drum their beaks against trees or wooden houses, rattlesnakes shake their tails, gorillas beat their chests, grasshoppers scrape their legs together, and termites grind their mandibles. The variety of resulting sounds is remarkable, ranging from the happy melodies of the robin to the mournful calls of the humpback whale; from the faint, rhythmic ticking of a beetle to the piercing shriek of a baboon. Although some of these animal sounds may just be idle chatter to break the silence, most serve to communicate messages to friends and to foes. Obviously, then, for the sender’s messages to be effective, those messages must be received by the other party. In nature, this is one of auditory perception’s primary jobs, enabling animals to hear what others have to say. Blake & Sekuler (2006, p. 428)


BP: Evidence based on sources*

  • Argument needs to be based on (scientific) sources

  • Keep personal experiences out of it

  • Keep it factual

  • Either cite and use quotations or;

  • Formulate it in your own words


* works cited  to be continued later

Coherence

  • Connect paragraphs by means of linking words

  • Paragraph should be one coherent piece

  • Essay should be coherent

construction

  • Separate paragraphs by means of a blank line (hence hit the enter button)

  • Only hit enter when starting a new paragraph

Bp1: example

Secondly, children do not care what St. Nicholas’ helper looks like, as long as they get their presents. The debate about ‘Zwarte Piet’ has caused a stir in the Netherlands. Surprisingly, the debate is solely between adults. While many keep saying that the tradition is to be kept because it is a children’s party, they are forgetting that the children do not care what ‘Zwarte Piet’ looks like. Dutch primary schools have abolished the offensive physical markings of ‘Zwarte Piet’ (Taylor, 2016), and while many parents are outraged, not one child seemed to care. Yes, they are fine with a black helper, but they are just as happy to receive their candy and presents from a red, yellow, orange, purple, blue, or green helper.


Works cited: in tekst (APA)

  • Always mention your source

  • Quotation or Paraphrasis

  • Author’s last name + year of publication

    • In text: (de Jager, 2018) or (Lindenburg, 2017, p. 12)

    • De Jager (2018) has stated that you should all “pass your exams” (p. 12).

  • At the end of essay: works cited list in alphabetical order

Works cited: list

  • References

  • See document (use this during the test)


Assignment

  • Write two topic sentences:

    • One for paragraph 1

    • One for paragraph 2

  • Then write two body paragraphs defending your argument

End of Lesson 3:
writing a body paragraph

  • You know how to write a body paragraph

  • You know what a body paragraph consists of

  • You know what a topic sentence is

  • You know how to write a topic sentence

  • You know how to make references


  • Homework:

    • Finish your two body paragraphs


  • Next lesson:

    • Writing a rebuttal/refutation


Lesson 4:
writing a refutation & Conclusion

  • Lesson aims:

    • You know what a refutation is

    • You can write a third body paragraph to your essay

    • You can write a conclusion



Rebuttal/refutation

When two people debate, one of them makes an argument, and the other follows with a rebuttal, which, plainly put, is the "no, you're wrong and this is why" argument.

Body paragraph 3

  • Rebuttal / refutation

  • Counter argument to strengthen your own argument

Body paragraph 3

  • Criteria

    • Opositional argument (Topic Sentence)

    • Clear refutation

    • Evidence based on sources

    • Coherence


  • SEXI

    • Statement = Topic sentence (first and most important sentence)

      • your argument in favor of statement

    • Explanation = Evidence for argument.

    • Illustration = Examples


BP: Topic sentence

  • = kernzin. In this case: start with counter argument and use it to strengthen your own argument.

  • Supports thesis statement

  • First few sentences of paragraph

  • Smoothly connected to previous paragraph

  • Contains the key point of this paragraph (which is your argument)

  • Backbone

  • Guides both author as well as reader

  • Highlight in yellow!


example

Thesis statement = Although ‘Zwarte Piet’ is one of the oldest Dutch traditions, it should be banned because it is incredibly racist and children do not care about their looks.


Topic sentence 3 = The most-used argument for the preservation of ‘Zwarte Piet’ is that it is a tradition.

Rebuttal = This is, however, no reason racism can be allowed.


Bp3: example

The most-used argument for the preservation of ‘Zwarte Piet’ is that it is a tradition. This is, however, no reason racism can be allowed. The tradition was shaped hundreds of years ago, in a totally different time. It was a time in which women did not have any rights, and in which slavery was legal. The traditions of then are not reflective of the Dutch society today. The present society is incredibly diverse, with many minorities in it, and everyone in that society should be respected.


Assignment 1

  • Find a counter argument that you can use to your advantage

  • Write topic sentence for third paragraph

  • Write a rebuttal for your third paragraph

  • Write third body paragraph

conclusion

  • End of paragraph: brief conclusion to emphasize your argument

  • Repeat thesis statement but in different words

  • Shows link to thesis statement

  • Different wording

  • Does not include new information

  • No new sources

  • Suggestion for future

example

Concluding, it seems inevitable that the tradition of ‘Zwarte Piet’ is going to have to change. The tradition is offensive to many people in both the Dutch society as well as the whole world. It is time to end this debate between adults about a children’s party, and respect everyone in the present society. Besides, there is an easy solution to the problem. If ‘Zwarte Piet’ gets his black looks from the chimney, why not make the face look like it has become black from actual soot instead of this ridiculous imagery of a slave? It is time to get rid of the current looks of ‘Zwarte Piet’.


Assignment 2

  • Write a conclusion

  • Do not forget suggestions for the future

End of Lesson 4:
writing a Rebuttal & conclusion

  • You know what a rebuttal is

  • You can write a third body paragraph to your essay

  • You can write a conclusion

  • You have finished writing a draft version of your mock essay


  • Next lesson:

    • Editing your essay

    • APA




Lesson 5:
Editing

  • Lesson aims:

    • You can rewrite your essay on:

      • Structure

      • Language

      • Referencing & Layout




Rewriting

  • The last step of the writing process is “rewriting”

    • Does your essay make sense as a whole?

    • Should certain sentences be improved upon?

    • Did you reference all your sources?

Structure tips

  • Connect paragraphs by means of linking words

  • Paragraph should be one coherent piece

  • Essay should be coherent as a whole

  • Separate paragraphs by means of a blank line (hence hit the enter button)

  • Only hit enter when starting a new paragraph



Effective topic sentence:

  1. State your main idea clearly

  2. Balance the topic sentence between specifics and general ideas

  3. Hook the reader

  4. Keep it short

  5. Give a reasonable opinion

  6. Use the topic sentence as a transition


Assignment 1

  • Peer feedback (round 1)

    • Give each other feedback on structure

Language tips

  • Stay formal

  • No contractions

  • No abbreviations

  • Avoid personal pronouns

  • Use passive voice

  • Use indirect speech

  • No questions

  • No announcements

  • Use linking words (signal words and function words!)


Assignment 2

  • Peer feedback (Round 2)

    • Give each other feedback on language

Referencing tips

  • Always mention your source

  • Quotation or Paraphrasis

  • Author’s last name + year of publication

    • In text: (de Jager, 2018) or (Lindenburg, 2017, p. 12)

    • De Jager (2018) has stated that you should all “pass your exams” (p. 12).

  • At the end of essay: works cited list in alphabetical order

Works cited: list

  • References

  • See document (use this during the test)


Plagiarism check

“Eat a banana, black monkey.” (CNN, 2015) These words were hurled at African-American director Roger Ross Williams when he announced his documentary called ‘Blackface’.

Versus

Eat a banana, black monkey. These words were hurled at African-American director Roger Ross Williams when he announced his documentary called ‘Blackface’.

Layout

  • Did you:

    • Use blank lines between paragraphs?

    • Include a title?

    • Avoid sub hearders?

    • Avoid starting a new sentence on a new line


  • Is your essay in general legible?

Assignment 3

  • Peer feedback (Round 3)

    • Give each other feedback on referencing

Assignment 4

Rewrite your essay

  • Firstly, focus on structure

    • Secondly, focus on language

    • Thirdly, focus on referencing

End of Lesson 5:
EDITING

  • You can rewrite your essay on structure, language, and referencing

  • You can provide feedback on structure, language, and referencing



  • Homework

    • Finish rewriting your mock essay for teacher feedback