Lesson 5
Who controls economic power?
Lesson 5
Who controls economic power?
Lesson 5 Who controls economic power?
By the end of the lesson, the student can...
identify and explain the characteristics of monopoly, oligopoly and monopolistic competition.
analyse how market power affects prices, output, consumer choice and producer behaviour.
evaluate whether government intervention is justified when firms have significant market power.
justify a competition-policy decision by weighing efficiency, consumer welfare, innovation and economic freedom.
Imagine that one company becomes the only provider of the internet connection in your country.
It can decide:
the price you pay;
the speed of your connection;
which services receive priority;
and the conditions of your contract.
There are no other companies you can switch to.
Choose a number from 1 to 5, and explain your choice
1 — Government should do nothing
5 — Government should heavily regulate the company
second
“If a company becomes economically powerful, who should control that power?”
Make assignment 1
minute
second
Four market structures
Market structure → market power → firm behaviour → market outcome
Today
Presentations
Finish inquiry: Lesson 5 Who controls economic power?
Start lesson 6 Who should pay for progress?
Hearing
The government is concerned that the market power may be reducing competition.
Your task is to represent your assigned stakeholder and argue whether the government should intervene.
You have 5 minutes to prepare.
During the hearing, you have 2 minutes to present your position to the authority
You must:
Use at least two economic concepts.
Present at least one argument supporting your position.
Present at least one argument against your own position.
Respond to at least one other student's argument.
Finish by making a clear policy recommendation.
minute
second
Simulation Market Round 1
Firm Lorin, Firm Sude, Firm Yulia, Firm Jent
Each firm sells the same product.
There are 100 consumers in the market.
Each firm chooses a price secretly between €5 and €10
second
Position Consumers
Lowest price 50
2nd lowest 30
3rd lowest 15
Highest price 5
Calculate your revenue
=Price * Quantity
Simulation Market Round 2
Firm Lorin, Firm Sude, Firm Yulia, Firm Jent
Each firm sells the same product.
There are 100 consumers in the market.
“You now know what your competitors did in Round 1. You are about to compete again. This time, you may discuss strategy with the other firms for 2 minutes.”
minute
second
Position Consumers
Lowest price 50
2nd lowest 30
3rd lowest 15
Highest price 5
Calculate your revenue
=Price * Quantity
Analyse
Did prices increase or decrease?
Did firms behave differently after communicating?
Why might firms want to coordinate?
Who benefits if all firms keep prices high?
Who loses?
What could happen if one firm secretly breaks the agreement?
Should the government allow firms to make such agreements?
minute
second
Oligopoly → strategic interdependence → collusion → cartel → competition policy.
Cartel = A group of firms that cooperate to restrict competition, for example by agreeing on prices or output.
Is Monopoly Always Bad?
Agree or disagree, give a argument and counterargument
Claim 1:
“Monopolies are always bad because consumers have no choice.”
Claim 2:
“A monopoly can sometimes be more efficient than having many competing firms.”
Natural monopoly = A market where one large firm can produce at a lower average cost than several competing firms because of very large economies of scale.
Possible examples for discussion:
water networks
electricity networks
railway infrastructure
Should society create competition if competition makes the product more expensive?
competition ↔ efficiency
consumer choice ↔ economies of scale
Who controls economic power?
Complete the sentence:
“Economic power should be controlled by ______ because ______. However, ______.”