Lesson 37 - Further Scrutiny Backbenchers, Opposition PMQs.pptx

Key defeat examples

  1. 2004 Hunting Act: House of Lords opposition

  • Saw 1911/49 Parliament Acts used for only 7th time since 1911

  1. Numerous Brexit examples – most notable would be Theresa May’s January 2019 parliamentary defeat over her Brexit deal

  • 432 to 202 in favour of rejecting the deal, represented the largest defeat for a sitting government in modern history (since 1924)



What did this lead to for Theresa?

1 / 15
next
Slide 1: Slide
New lesson editorEngelsMiddelbare schoolvmbo kLeerjaar 1

This lesson contains 15 slides, with text slides.

Report this lesson

Items in this lesson

Key defeat examples

  1. 2004 Hunting Act: House of Lords opposition

  • Saw 1911/49 Parliament Acts used for only 7th time since 1911

  1. Numerous Brexit examples – most notable would be Theresa May’s January 2019 parliamentary defeat over her Brexit deal

  • 432 to 202 in favour of rejecting the deal, represented the largest defeat for a sitting government in modern history (since 1924)



What did this lead to for Theresa?

Today’s Aims & Intentions

  • Today’s Aim = To assess the effectiveness of various forms of Parliamentary scrutiny over the Executive


  • Intentions – By the end of this session, you will be able to:

  1. Outline one strength & one limitation of Backbenchers’ ability to hold the government to account

  2. Outline two strengths & two flaws of ‘Questioning Ministers’ in Parliament

  3. Assess how effectively Parliament can hold the executive to account

  4. Reach a conclusion over which House is more effective in holding the government to account


Backbenchers

  • ‘Lobby Fodder’, who vote and do as party says?

  • Concept of ‘Parliamentary Privilege’

    • MPs being free to speak without fear of prosecution for slander within Parliament’s walls

  • Independence: Since 2007, backbenchers have become more independent than in previous decades –backbenchers often negotiate with governments to get amendments before voting

  • Select Committees emphasise backbench independence – membership no longer controlled by whips so more likely to embarrass government?

Forms of Scrutiny

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2011/may/23/ryan-giggs-mp-injunction

Urgent Questions

  • If an urgent or important matter arises which an MP believes requires an immediate answer from a government minister, they may apply to ask an urgent question

  • Speaker considers applications – if granted, receive an oral answer from minister on the same day

  • Former Speaker John Bercow was a major champion of backbench rights – granted over 150 urgent questions from 2009-2014

Forms of Scrutiny

Tory backbench strife…

As you watch, make notes:


  • What problems did Liz Truss have with backbenchers?

  • What about Theresa May?

Tory MP visibly furious over party chaos: 'the damage they have done is extraordinary' - YouTube

The Brexit Mistakes That Led to Theresa May's Resignation (HBO)

Famous backbench rebellions

  1. Thatcher, 1986: Shops Bill, providing Sunday trading, defeated by 14 votes

  2. Blair, 2005: 90-day terrorist suspect detention rejected with 49 rebels, 322 vs 291

  3. Cameron, 2013: Action in Syria, lost by 13 votes

  4. May, 2018-19: EU Withdrawal Agreement (3 Defeats on whole deal – 15th Jan, 12th March & 29th March 2019)

  5. Johnson, 2019: Boris Johnson removing the whip from 21 MP’s who voted against Brexit plan

  6. Truss, 2022: Ousted by backbench pressure

Brexit showdown: Who were Tory rebels who defied Boris Johnson? - BBC News

Backbench Business Committee

  • Established in 2010

  • Chair must be an opposition member, with membership again reflecting composition of Commons (8 members)

  • Backbenchers allowed to choose topics to debate for 35 days of the year (approx. one day a week) – this committee manages this

  • Topics can be chosen by individual backbenchers, or via e-petitions signed by the public, with decisions on what is discussed chosen by the committee

  • Gives backbenchers more say and power over Parliament’s debates

Forms of Scrutiny

Limits to Backbench powers

  1. Whips:

  • Entice them with giving positive reports on them to PMs ahead of governments reshuffles (‘carrots’)

OR…

  • Threatening to reveal embarrassing information about MPs to the media and scuppering promotions (‘sticks’)

  1. Whipping System: Three-line whip – refusal could see expulsion

  2. Resources: Backbenchers have limited research and admin staff compared to government

  3. Majority: Government with large Commons majority means government dominance usually – backbenchers tend to accept government’s plans & vote with them, even if they may disagree

Forms of Scrutiny

Backbench support depends on…

  1. Ambition: If they think PM is there for the long-term, ambitious MPs will vote with PM to please them as they appoint Cabinet & government

  2. Keeping their Seat: An MP in a more marginal seat will be more likely to support a popular PM - enhance chances of re-election

  3. Supports the PM’s Agenda: Vote with PM simply because they like them & agree with their policies

  4. Dislikes the PM’s Agenda: Equally, backbenchers who don’t like the PM/ policies are less likely to vote for them

Forms of Scrutiny

Votes of no confidence

  • Can dismiss the government of the day and call an election

    • Only needs a simple majority to pass

    • Only proposed in House of Commons

    • Last loss: James Callaghan in 1979 (311-310)

    • Recent examples: May (Jan 2019) and Johnson (July 2022 – after he resigned), but both survived

Forms of Scrutiny

Activities of The Opposition

  • Ability to scrutinise the executive is limited by factors beyond its control

    • Size & Unity of governing party

    • Length of time government has been in power

  • But well-coordinated opposition can still influence popularity & power of a government

    • Blair opposition of 1994-1997 presenting Major’s weaknesses effectively, and simultaneously showed themselves as a great alternative

    • Cameron opposition (2005-2010) underlined divisions in Labour Party, with Blair vs Brown tensions & exploiting crises’ like the 2008 financial crash

Forms of Scrutiny

What is Questioning?

  • Formally asking members of government questions within Parliament’s chambers

  • Allows MPs or Peers to question government ministers on decisions, policies & actions they/their departments have made



Prime minister’s questions

  • Wednesdays at 12 noon in House of Commons once a week

  • Gives the Leader of the Opposition, and then backbench MPs, a chance to question the Prime Minister on current issues, policy areas of debate, or raise issues & concerns to government on the behalf of their constituents

  • Conduct chaired by the Speaker

Effective Example? How can we argue this is effective scrutiny? What impact did it have?


'Gone! Gone! Gone!': Keir Starmer v Liz Truss (2022)


Questioning & PMQs = Effective scrutiny?

Strengths

  1. PMQs forces PM to be well-informed about policy agenda & wider news

  2. Leader of the opposition can apply pressure & expose any major government mistakes

  3. PMQs is significant & unique globally, plus can lead to success… Corbyn overturning premium rate number to call Universal Credit

  4. Urgent Questions: Demand attendance of relevant minister to answer questions and face criticism


Flaws

  1. Too many questions from ‘friendly’ government backbenchers

  2. PMQS = Political & Media theatre rather than proper scrutiny? Theatrics are a media distraction from more complex, less ‘sexy’ issues

  3. PMQs is about point-scoring: ‘Punch and Judy’ with MPs cheering and shouting in a childish manner – leads to public apathy & dislike of politics/politicians



Reform inbound?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckgyleldl27o