Unit 2: Argument – Comparing Claims and Evidence
Texts: The Automation Paradox (James Bessen) & Heads Up, Humans (Claudia Alarcón)
Unit 2: Argument – Comparing Claims and Evidence
Texts: The Automation Paradox (James Bessen) & Heads Up, Humans (Claudia Alarcón)
Lesson Objectives
By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:
Identify claims and supporting evidence in an argument text.
Compare arguments across two texts using a comparison chart.
Analyze how graphic features support an argument.
Write a short argument paragraph using evidence and transitional words.
Key Vocabulary
• redistribute
• robustly
• expansive
• predominantly
• collaborate
Transitional Words & Phrases
Examples:
• however
• in contrast
• for example
• as a result
• therefore
• on the other hand
Text A: The Automation Paradox (James Bessen)
Main Claim: Automation creates new opportunities and jobs.
Evidence: Example of ATMs leading to more bank tellers due to expansion.
Tone: Optimistic and confident.
Text B: Heads Up, Humans (Claudia Alarcón)
Main Claim: Automation threatens jobs and creates economic challenges.
Evidence: Experts predict AI/robots will replace many workers.
Tone: Cautious, warning readers to prepare.
Model Comparison Chart
Feature | Text A (Bessen) | Text B (Alarcón)
Claim: Jobs created vs. Jobs lost
Evidence: Historical example vs. Predictions
Tone: Optimistic vs. Cautious
Message: Don’t fear vs. Be cautious
Guided Practice
Task: In pairs, complete a blank comparison chart.
Use claims, evidence, and transitional words.
Sentence Starter: In Text A, the author argues that ____, but in Text B, the author argues that ____.
Writing Practice
Write a short paragraph with:
• A claim
• At least one piece of evidence
• Two transitional words
• One vocabulary word
Exit Ticket
Question:
Which author makes the stronger argument about automation? Why?