Today
Short Recap question
Lesson 3 – When Markets Fail
Today
Short Recap question
Lesson 3 – When Markets Fail
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
To what extent can the market system be considered a form of governance?”
scarcity
incentives
demand
supply
price mechanism
equilibrium
resource allocation
consumer sovereignty
government intervention
efficiency
equity
market power
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
If markets coordinate individual choices, why might societies still need governments to intervene?
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Lesson 3 – When Markets Fail
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Lesson 3 – When Markets Fail
Explain why a market equilibrium can produce an inefficient allocation of resources.
Distinguish between negative externalities, positive externalities, public goods and information failure.
Analyse how market failure affects different stakeholders and creates a role for government intervention.
Evaluate whether a government intervention is likely to improve the market outcome, considering possible unintended consequences.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Scenario
A company wants to build a large factory next to a river.
The factory will create jobs, produce cheap products and generate profits.
However, the production process may pollute the river.
The company can choose:
A. Clean production: €2 million cost
B. Normal production: €0.5 million cost, but causes significant pollution
Who should pay for the pollution?
second
The company
Consumers
The government
Local residents
Nobody
Your role
Lorin– Factory owner
Your objective: maximize profit.
Yulia – Local resident
Your objective: minimize the damage to your community.
Jent – Government minister
Your objective: maximize overall social welfare.
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Negotiate/Discuss
You must argue from your economic incentive(s), not simply from your personal opinion.
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Question 1 - What does the company consider when making its decision?
Question 2 -What costs and benefits does society experience that the company does not consider?
Question 3 - Would the market automatically take the €9m social damage into account?
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
"The factory is profitable. Consumers want its products. Workers want the jobs. Yet the outcome may still be inefficient."
How is that possible?
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
This is one example of
MARKET FAILURE.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
"If the government forces the company to pay for the pollution, has the government solved the market failure?"
Identify at least one problem with government intervention
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Possible ideas
How does the government know the true cost of pollution?
What if the tax is too high?
What if the company moves elsewhere?
What if regulation destroys jobs?
Who decides what level of pollution is acceptable?
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Individual incentives → Market outcome → Social costs → Market failure → Government intervention → Possible government failure
When markets fail to produce socially desirable outcomes, how should societies be governed?
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Conclusion
Private costs/benefits ≠ Social costs/benefits
"If the market price does not include all the costs and benefits experienced by society, what might happen?"
The market may allocate too many or too few resources to an activity.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
So What Exactly Failed?
Market failure occurs when...
Market failure occurs when the free market fails to allocate resources efficiently, resulting in an outcome that does not maximize social welfare
The market produces an outcome, but the outcome is inefficient from society's perspective.
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Case 1 – Pollution
A factory produces €10 million worth of products. It earns a profit, but pollution causes €3 million of environmental damage to nearby communities.
Case 2 – Vaccination
A person gets vaccinated. They benefit personally, but their vaccination also reduces the probability of others becoming infected.
Case 3 – Street lighting
A city installs streetlights. People can benefit from the lighting even if they don't directly pay for each unit of light they consume.
Case 4 – Second-hand cars
A seller knows whether a car has serious mechanical problems. The buyer cannot easily observe this information.
minute
second
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
You are the management team of a factory producing smartphones.
The factory can increase production to earn more revenue. However, production creates air pollution that affects people living nearby.
Your task is to decide how many smartphones the factory should produce.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Which units should the factory produce if it only considers its own costs and consumers' willingness to pay?
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
"But what has the factory ignored?"
"What is the actual cost to society of producing each unit?"
Deze slide heeft geen instructies