Step 3: Debattle!
Building a strong argument
Step 3: Debattle!
Building a strong argument
1 ⁄ From arguments to rebuttals
(We skip this part - we will discuss this in the 6th form)
2 ⁄ Build your argument
Ex. 1
To make a point, you will need to come up with strong arguments. Read the essay ‘The impressionable mind: why marketing food to children is unethical’ and answer
the questions 1 a-b-c-d-e
a Which problem does the statement address? What is the subject of the statement?
a Which problem does the statement address? What is the subject of the statement?
marketing food to children
Why is this a problem?
Why is this a problem?
It is contributing to many of the problems that America has with health and healthy eating, and is very unethical.
c Who is involved? What effect does it have on these people?
c Who is involved? What effect does it have on these people?
Children, especially pre-adolescents, parents and even schools are all involved. They cannot tackle this problem without stronger measures being taken (i.e. restricting advertising by junk food companies).
d What are the negative consequences of marketing junk food to children? Name 2.
d What are the negative consequences of marketing junk food to children? Name 2.
– Children begin to desire the marketed food and they lack the decision-making skills and autonomy necessary to make good personal choices about food.
– Children don’t understand the manipulative nature of marketing of usually heavily-processed food, which only contributes to America’s obesity problem.
e Which counterargument is also rebutted here?
(to rebut = to argue that a statement or claim is not true; 'weerleggen')
e Which counterargument is also rebutted here?
That it is the parents’ job to protect their children from untoward influences. But parents cannot be everywhere all the time.
f When writing such an argumentative essay, there are a few fundamental steps you can take to structure an argument effectively. Match these 5 steps to the corresponding paragraph.
A
B
C
D
E
Ex. 2
Look at the statement below.
Follow the step-by-step plan to build 3 strong
arguments that defend the statement.
‘Schools should ban vending machines that sell unhealthy snacks and drinks.’
Work together!
minute
second
a Which problem does the statement address? Why is it a problem?
argument 1
b Who is involved? What effect does it have on these people?
argument 2
c What would be a positive consequence of banning these vending machines?
argument 3
suggested answers:
Ex. 3
Look at the conjunctions and phrases underlined in the essay in exercise 1 on p. 37.
Add them to the correct column.
When
First of all
while
however
Moreover
so that
Unlike
If ... then
(This is true,) but
for instance
In conclusion
When
First of all
while
however
Moreover
so that
Unlike
If ... then
(This is true,) but
for instance
In conclusion
while
however
Unlike
(This is true,) but
for instance
when
so that
If...then
First of all
Moreover
In conclusion
additionally
(such) as
as a result
also
alternatively
although
besides
to conclude
consequently
despite
equally
finally
first(ly), second(ly), third(ly)
for example
for this reason
furthermore
hence
to illustrate
in addition
in contrast
in the same way
last(ly)
like
namely
on the contrary
on the other hand
similarly
since
summarising
to sum up
therefore
thus
yet
Ex. 4 Add these phrases and conjunctions to the table too. Look them up online if necessary.
additionally
(such) as
as a result
also
alternatively
although
besides
to conclude
consequently
despite
equally
finally
while
however
Unlike
(This is true,) but
for instance
when
so that
If...then
First of all
Moreover
In conclusion
first(ly), second(ly), third(ly)
for example
for this reason
furthermore
hence
o illustrate
in addition
in contrast
in the same way
last(ly)
like
namely
on the contrary
on the other hand
similarly
since
summarising
to sum up
therefore
thus
yet
Ex. 5
Read part of the essay on sustainable eating below. Fill in an appropriate conjunction.
Choose from the box.
but – finally – however – in addition – in conclusion – such as – therefore – thus (2x)
Thus
Thus
However
Thus
However
In addition
Thus
However
In addition
therefore
thus
thus
But
thus
But
Finally
thus
But
Finally
such as
thus
But
Finally
such as
In conclusion
3/ No room for logical fallacies
Ex. 1
When building a strong argument, you should make sure you respect the rules of logic.
Look at the arguments. Do you think they are valid or not? In other words, do they make sense? Are they logical? Tick the right box.
1 Eating meat is not unhealthy. Our family has been eating meat for centuries and none of us has been seriously ill.
valid
not valid
2 Lean meat, such as chicken or turkey, is not bad for you, because it’s a rich source of protein, which provides health benefits for the body.
valid
not valid
3 I don’t believe in global warming. My cousin is a top surgeon in South Africa, and he says the drought has not gotten worse at all.
valid
not valid
4 If you keep smoking cigarettes, your risk of developing coronary heart disease increases.
valid
not valid
5 – Daughter: ‘Mom, I’m too full, I can’t eat anymore.’ – Mother: ‘You have to eat everything on your plate; think of all the children in Africa who are starving every day.'
valid
not valid
6 If you don’t stop smoking cigarettes, you are going to start shooting heroin.
valid
not valid
7 Vegetables are bad for you! After all, the dinosaurs ate plants and we all know what happened to them, don’t we?
valid
not valid
8 Research does suggest that vegans have a lower risk of heart disease, but that same research also indicates they have a higher risk of strokes, possibly due to B12 deficiency.
valid
not valid
9 If we don’t order pizza for dinner, I guess we’ll just have to eat the week-old spaghetti in the fridge.
valid
not valid
10 You have no idea what you’re talking about; you’ve only lived here for 6 months.
valid
not valid
11 A group of teenagers vandalised the park downtown. Teenagers are irresponsible and destructive.
valid
not valid
12 80 % of people are for the death penalty, therefore, the death penalty is moral.
valid
not valid
13 – ‘I believe we should spend less money on the military.’ – ‘Can you believe this? My opponent wants to leave us defenceless. We all deserve better!’
valid
not valid
Ex. 2
Most of the arguments listed in exercise 1 are examples of ‘logical fallacies’.
Let’s focus on a few. Watch the video. Answer the questions.
a What is a logical fallacy?
b Write the names of the logical fallacies mentioned in the video next to their definition.
c Now add the names of these 4 common logical fallacies next to the corresponding definition.
Ex. 2
a What is a logical fallacy?
A logical fallacy is a faulty argument. A claim may sound convincing in the moment, but if you stop and examine it, it does not stand up to the test of logic.
(= een drogreden)
appeal to emotion
hasty generalisation
slippery slopen
straw man argument
false causet
appeal to popularity/
common sense fallacy
false dilemma
personal attack
appeal to authority/
false authority
appeal to tradition
1
3
5
6
7
9
10
11
12
13
Ex. 3
Which logical fallacies from exercise 2 do you recognise in the videos?
slippery slope
slippery slope
personal attack
slippery slope
personal attack
false cause
slippery slope
personal attack
false cause
an appeal to authority/false authority
Ex. 4
What about this ad?
Ex. 4
What about this ad?
CHECK OUT
ORIENTATION
You are going to post a thread about (sustainable) foods on a bulletin board and react to other threads.
Which topic would you like to hold a debate about (on a discussion forum)? Pick a statement from p. 71. Take the poll.
Your teacher will decide whether you are PRO or CONTRA.
Look up arguments that you can use to uphold your opinion.
Make sure to include conditionals.
originalType.poll
ACTION
Write your thread in the Bookwidget.
State your opinion. In other words, answer the question, “What do you think?”
State why you think what you think.
Provide different arguments.
Add a catchy title that will attract readers.
Use at least 3 conditional sentences in your thread.
Select everything before sending in your text.
Copy your text and go to the Padlet. Log in with your eduso-account. Paste your thread:
React to your classmates’ posts. Do this at least 3 times.