Rule of Law: Power, Rights & Justice
Rule of Law: Power, Rights & Justice
State of Nature
A hypothetical condition without laws or government, leading to insecurity and chaos.
Thomas Hobbes and Social Contract
Hobbes argued people in the the social contract gave up some freedom to the government for collective safety and order.
What is the rule of law?
The Rule of Law means that all people and institutions, including the government, are subject to and accountable under the law.
Law Governs Everyone
No one is above the law—not even the government. Laws apply equally to citizens, officials, and authorities.
Purpose of the rule of law
It maintains order, protects the citizens' rights and freedoms, prevents abuse of power, and upholds justice.
Threefold Protection
The Rule of Law protects individuals:
Against fellow citizens
Against the government
By the government
Four Key Principles
The Rule of Law is underpinned by: 1. Principle of legality 2. Fundamental rights 3. Separation of powers 4. Independent and impartial judiciary
Principle of Legality
Definition
A person can only be punished for actions that were criminal by law at the time they committed them.
and
Even the government must adhere to legal standards and be accountable for its actions.
Fundamental Rights
Distinguish between classical rights (e.g., freedom of expression, religion, assembly) and social rights (e.g., education, housing, healthcare).
Sleepvraag
Classical rights
Social rights
Freedom of religion
Freedom of demonstration
Right to housing
Right to education
Government’s Role & Individual Rights
The government is obligated to protect rights, but must also respect individual freedoms.
This balance is central to exam questions.
Separation of Powers
Legislative power
→ Parliament (Staten-Generaal (2e + 1e Kamer)
Makes and changes laws
Approves the government’s budget
Executive power
→ Government (Cabinet)
Executes and enforces laws
Develops policy and governs the country
Judicial power
→ Courts (Judiciary)
Interprets laws
Settles disputes
Judges criminal and civil cases
Independent and Impartial Judiciary
Judges must be unbiased and free from external influences when making decisions.
No Hierarchy of Rights
Fundamental rights are equal; there is no ranking. Rights may conflict in particular cases.
Clash of Fundamental Rights
Examples: - Freedom of speech vs. right to privacy - Freedom of religion vs. non-discrimination Judges balance rights based on case law.
Two Constitutional Systems
Netherlands: parliamentary sovereignty United States: constitutional supremacy
In The Netherlands a judge cannot check if a law is against the constitution. The parliament should check that.
In the US the constitutional court can do that.
Criminal Justice & Rule of Law
Principle of legality: behaviour is only criminal if defined by law beforehand.
When is Something a Crime?
After the introduction follows:
Purposes of Punishment
Retribution (repayment for crime),
deterrence (discouraging crime),
rehabilitation (reintegrating offender),
safety (protecting society).
International Rule of Law
The International Criminal Court (ICC) enforces global justice. States maintain sovereignty, creating tension with international law.
Interactive: Quick Poll
Which principle do you think is most important for the Rule of Law? - Principle of legality - Separation of powers - Fundamental rights - Independent judiciary
Think-Pair-Share
Consider this dilemma: Should freedom of speech ever be limited to protect other rights? Discuss your reasoning with a partner.
Write down 3 things you learned in this lesson.
Write down 2 things you want to know more about.
Ask 1 question about something you haven't quite understood yet.