Specification
explain, evaluate and analyse psychological theories, concepts, research evidence and terminology when explaining human behaviour
give psychological explanations, evaluation and analysis of social behaviour through the topics of conformity and obedience
factors affecting obedience, which must include:
— perceived legitimate authority
— socialisation
— authoritarian parenting
— autonomous and agentic levels of behaviour
— situational factors: proximity, location, wearing a uniform
the aims, methods, results, evaluation and conclusions of Milgram, S. (1963). Behavioural study of obedience. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology 67, 371–78, and relevant knowledge from Milgram’s subsequent related studies
What is obedience?
Can be defined as changing behaviour or beliefs in response to a direct command or instruction.
Comes from a person in a position of power who is not doing the same thing.
Both conformity and obedience are forms of social pressure, but conformity comes from peers.
Perceived legitimate authority – (situational factor)
A lot of society is structured as a heirarchy which means those in 'lower ranks' are expected to obey those higher up.
Examples include – employees obey managers, children obey parents, general public obey police, rating obeys officer
These are seen as legitimate authority figures
Sometimes this isn't clear and someone may give an order but the person isn't sure whether to obey or not as they are not sure if the authority is legitimate.
Max Weber
Suggested legitimate authority comes from three main source.
1. Tradition – in each society some groups are considered to have more authority
2. Legal – some people have legal authority that if you do not obey leads to punishment
3. Charisma – some people have personal charm and despite a lack of legitimate authority can convince others that they do
For example Cult leaders – Manson, Waco,
Bickman 1974 – Power dressing
When trying to work out if someone has authority over us we look for clues. One of the clues that has an impact is how someone is dressed.
Bickman asked actors to give passers-by instructions such as 'pick up the litter'
The actors were dressed as either – casual clothes, as a milkman or as a security guard.
19% obeyed the civilian
14% obeyed the milkman
38% obeyed the security guard
Bickman 1974
It was concluded that the type of uniform matters to give legitimacy to an order.
But needs to have matching social power
(Link to Milgram's further studies in which he changed the clothing of the experimenter from lab coat to casual clothing)
Socialisation – societal
The result of collective social pressures means that we are taught to respect and obey authority figures.
This effect of childhood experiences on making us behave in accordance to collective social pressure is called socialisation. (Anderson & Zimbardo, 1984)
Parenting style – Individual/Societal
Parenting style has a large impact on the socialisation of a child.
Authoritarian parenting - parents teach their children to obey and respect authority figures as a top priority. This style of parenting results in the most obedient children (Adorno 1950, Baumrind 1971). - leads to more obedient adults
Democratic parenting – parents teach their children that rules are not absolute and encourage them to negotiate boundaries. - Leads to less obedient adults
Agency theory - Milgram
Deciding whether to obey or not can be affected by a person's mental state according to Milgram.
Most of the time we act according to our own wishes - autonomous state
When under pressure or moral stress we tend to look for authority figures to follow (as we have been socialised in a hierarchy) and we relinquish own moral responsibility and act on others' orders – agentic state
Hofling et al 1966
A study that supports Milgram's agency theory was conducted by Hofling.
Would nurses administer an unsafe dosage of medicine under unjust instructions from a doctor?
Nurses were rung by a fake Dr who asked them to administer a dose of a new drug to a patient.
He would sign the papers when he got there.
The medicine bottle was clearly labelled with what should be a safe dosage.
Hofling et al 1966
21 out of 22 (95%) nurses obeyed without resistance.
It was concluded that nurses were working in an agentic state as most were aware they were breaking hospital rules.
Valid results as it has high ecological validity and participants were not aware they were in an experiment
(link to Milgram)
Question time
Give one real-world example of obedience
Describe the characteristics of authoritarian parenting
Briefly explain what effect socialisation can have on obedience.
Briefly explain what is meant by a perceived legitimate authority figure.