Should Everyone Get a Second Chance? - by Katharine Viner
In the film Coach Carter, a basketball coach benches his entire team—not because they’re losing, but because they aren’t meeting academic expectations. His decision surprises many, including the players themselves. Some call him too strict, while others admire his focus on education over sports. But the most powerful message in the film is about second chances.
Many of the players had poor attendance, bad grades, or negative attitudes when Coach Carter arrived. However, he believed in their potential. He gave them strict rules but also a new chance to succeed—on and off the court.
This raises a big question: should people always get a second chance? Some say yes, because young people often make mistakes and can learn from them. Others argue that second chances should be earned, not simply given.
At school, in sports, and even in life, we are often judged by our past actions. But isn’t it more important who we choose to become?
What do you think? Should schools, teachers, and coaches always give second chances—or are some mistakes too serious?