The Soldier &
Dulce et Decorum Est
5V Literature
The Soldier &
Dulce et Decorum Est
5V Literature
The Soldier
Rupert Brooke
About the author
Rupert Brooke
1887 - 1915
What does the year of his death (1915) tell us?
About the author
Brooke also died during WWI.
Joined the Royal Navy.
Killed by an infection after a mosquito bite.
What do the following words mean?
foreign
to bear
concealed
shed away
gentleness
gorgelend
zachtheid
buitenlands
verdwenen
bevallen
verstopt
Slide titel
What are the two elements that you need to describe as a setting?
What is the setting of this poem?
What is the setting of this poem?
Time: WWI
Place: England!
England in a foreign field
England gave life to the person
English air
English heaven
How many stanzas does this poem have?
1
2
8 & 6
14
Sonnet
This poem is a sonnet because it has 14 lines
8 in the first stanza (octave)
6 in the second stanza (sestet)
Brooke combines two sonnet traditions:
the rhyme scheme of the first eight lines follows the Shakespearean model (ABABCDCD),
the last six lines follow the Petrarchan (Italian) model (EFGEFG).
Connect the perspectives to the description.
Narrator is participant in the story.
Neither narrator nor reader is participant in the story. Narrator follows a singular character.
Neither narrator nor reader is participant in the story. Narrator knows thoughts of multiple characters.
omniscient perspective
first-person perspective
third-person perspective
second-person perspective
multiple person perspective
4. In which perspective is this poem written?
first-person perspective
third-person perspective
omniscient perspective
First person perspective
The narrator can only tell what he or she knows, sees, hears and thinks. The first-person narrator has no knowledge of what the other characters think and speaks as “I”. This narrator is also a participant in the story and the he or she is the one who reveals the plot.
5. What does the author mean with richer dust in line 4?
Correct answer:
Rich earth → earth is rich because it is England
Richer dust → his body (from ashes to ashes, from dust to dust)
What type of imagery is this?
metaphor
personification
simile
Correct answer:
It is a metaphor that describes his body that enriches the soil.
Metaphor: comparison without the use of like or as.
Let's continue
Dulce Est Decorum Est
Dulce et Decorum Est
About the author
Wilfred Owen
1893 - 1918
What does the year of his death (1918) tell us?
About the author
Owen died during WWI.
He had enlisted voluntarily.
Killed one week before the
armistice (wapenstilstand)
was signed.
What do the following words mean?
knock-kneed
gargling
plunges
stumbling
fumbling
lame
gorgelend
grijpen
met x-benen
struikelend
kreupel
geklungel
Let's read the text together
Title: Dulce et Decorum Est
Where do we find the complete title?
The old lie: Dulce et decorum est Pro patria Mori
= it is sweet and fitting to die for one's country.
Horace: Roman poet and soldier (Horatio)
Government wanted soldiers to believe this.
carved into the entrance of Sandhurst Acadamy (= military acadamy)
Title: Dulce et Decorum Est
The old lie: Dulce et decorum est Pro patria Mori
= it is sweet and fitting to die for one's country.
Why is it a lie (leugen)?
It is not sweet and honorable. The complete opposite: it is horrible!
Owen's attitude towards the war was...
positive
negative
1. What is the setting of this poem?
What is the setting of this poem?
Time: WWI
Place: on a battlefield (back towards their camp)
What is a stanza?
a type of poem
a group of lines forming a unit in a poem
12 lines in a poem
Describe in your own words what happens in the first two stanzas.
Discuss in pairs or groups of three
minute
second
Stanza 1
Tired soldiers are walking back to their camp from a battlefield. Suddenly they are attacked by their enemy who uses gas.
Stanza 2
The soldiers put on their masks. One, however, fails to do so and is choking in the gas. (He isn’t dead yet, but he is dying!)
Connect the figure of speech to the description.
A comparison without the words as or like.
A comparison with the words as or like.
A lifeless object is given a human trait.
personification
metaphor
simile
Question
Examine the two figures of speech in the first two lines.
What figure of speech is this? Metaphor or simile?
metaphor
simile
What two things in each case are being compared?
3c. What image is created by these figures of speech?
Discuss this in pairs or groups of three
Correct answer:
The soldiers are a sorry sight, not the strong energetic men you normally associate with soldiers
The soldiers returning from the field were..
energetic
happy
tired
crying
What words show how tired the soldiers are? (Do not use the similes from question 1)
minute
second
Possible answers:
bent double (dubbel gevouwen; shows how they walk)
knock-kneed (x-benen)
trudge (sjokken)
men marched asleep
limped (strompelen)
lame (kreupel)
drunk with fatigue (vermoeidheid)
dear (to the hoots)
What do the stanza's focus on?
Stanza 1
Stanza 4
Stanza 3
Stanza 2
we: the soldiers
you = the reader
He = a dying soldier
I = speaker
"I saw him drowning". What happened?
What were Owen's intentions with writing the poem?
In Owen's view, it is ... to die for your country. (1 word)
Correct answer
Horrific and devastating: there is no glory, no beauty or honour in the way young men die.
Compare The Soldier to Dulce Et Decorum Est. What is the biggest difference between the two poems in terms of theme?
Possible answer:
The theme in Dulce Et… was that it was horrific and devastating to die for one’s country and not honourable at all.
The Soldier shows the opposite: your body enriches the foreign earth, so it is honourable to die for your country.
What could be a reason for the difference between the poems?
The Soldier (1914) vs Dulce et Decorum Est (1917)
Discuss this in pairs or groups of three
Notes:
The Soldier was written at beginning of the war (1914)
Beginning of war: patriotic, idealistic, naïve.
Dying in battle and claiming land was noble/heroic.
Nobody knew that war could be so devastating.
Dulce et Decorum Est was written during the war (1917)
Therefore more realistic view of war