The social contract
- Know what the social contract is and how the philosophers Hobbes, Rousseau, and Machiavelli thought about it.
-Be able to apply the theories in context
The social contract
- Know what the social contract is and how the philosophers Hobbes, Rousseau, and Machiavelli thought about it.
-Be able to apply the theories in context
Existentialism
Existentialism is the idea that human life has no fixed purpose.
According to Jean Paul Sartre you are what you do.
So who we are as a person/humans is determined by our choices.
The social contract
A hypothetical agreement between a leader/government and its people.
But how should this look like?
Human beings are naturally selfish, anxious, and focused on self-preservation.
In the state of nature, there is a “war of all against all.”
There is no safety, no justice, no morality.
Famous saying: “Life is solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.”
Thus: Without a strong leader/power a society would not work.
Humans are naturally good, free, and compassionate.
In the state of nature, people live relatively peacefully and simply.
Inequality and conflict only arise due to private property and the formation of society.
Thus: It is not humans, but society that corrupts.
Thomas Hobbes
Jean
Jacques
Rousseau
Redenen voor het sociaal contract:
Hobbes
Rousseau
People enter into a social contract to protect their freedom, not to give it up.
The aim is a community in which people make decisions together.
People enter into a social contract out of fear.
They desire safety and order.
Everyone transfers their power to a single sovereign (king or state).
The contract is an emergency solution to prevent chaos.
The contract should enable freedom, not restrict it.
True or false? According to Machiavelli Leaders should be morally good people.
True
False
Which virtues are important for a leader to have?According to Machiavelli?
CRISIS!!
You sit in groups of three. Each person will be a different philosopher (Hobbes, Rousseau or Machiavelli).
On the board will be a crisis, what would your philosopher say is going to happen and what should the leader do?
There are three rounds, you will be someone different each round.
Famine
There is not enough food! Some people are starting
to raid. What should the leader/community do?
1 minute: Think what would your philosopher say.
2 minutes per person explain to each other.
Support:
“According to Hobbes/Rousseau / Machiavelli, …”
“From this perspective, people are …”
“We believe that the best solution is …”
“This decision is necessary because …”
Protest
A big group of civilians are protesting against
the governments ideas about climate change.
What should you do? Oppress, listen, negotiate?
1 minute: Think what would your philosopher say.
2 minutes per person explain to each other.
Support:
“According to Hobbes/Rousseau / Machiavelli, …”
“From this perspective, people are …”
“We believe that the best solution is …”
“This decision is necessary because …”
Loss in trust
People are starting to loose trust in the government.
What will happen? What should the government do?
1 minute: Think what would your philosopher say.
2 minutes per person explain to each other.
Support:
“According to Hobbes/Rousseau / Machiavelli, …”
“From this perspective, people are …”
“We believe that the best solution is …”
“This decision is necessary because …”
Would Machiavelli agree more with the ideas of Hobbes or Rousseau? Explain why.
Which philosopher do you agree with most? Explain why.