Responsible Technology
Responsible Technology
Role of AI in Recruitment
Title & Hook
“An algorithm might determine who gets hired — but who will control the algorithm?”
Visuals: An animation of CV personas being screened by an AI “filter”.
Team Reflection (voiceover):
We picked this topic because AI is changing recruitment – entraining automatic candidate screening, interviews and sifting through application – but it poses deep ethical, legal, professional questions.
As emerging IT professionals, we must consider not just can we build these systems, but should — and if so, how.
Critical Reflection:
We chose “AI in Recruitment” after considering other AI domains (e.g., health, policing). Recruitment was a moment that felt personal and ethically urgent — where abstract algorithms met real people.
Why This Topic?
Recruitment AI touches directly on people’s lives and their equality of opportunity.
The risks of harm — bias, privacy breaches or inscrutable decisions — are high.
The advantages — efficiency, cost-saving from less human error — are appealing.
We wanted a topic that illustrates how ethics, law and professionalism play into the development of technology that can help save lives.
: Ethical Issue — Algorithmic Bias
& Fairness
Ethical Issue Identified:
*Algorithmic bias contributing to hiring discrimination. *.
Structured Ethical Analysis:
Ethical Risk Zones (Ethical OS Framework):
Zone 4: Machine Ethics & Algorithmic Bias** — AI picks up human bias.
Zone 5: Surveillance & Data Control** -- (data extraction) invasive data collection at time of screening.
Zone 7: Implicit Trust & User Understanding** — employers over-trust AI “objectivity.”
Zone 3: Economic Inequality** — discriminatory tools exacerbate employment disparities.
Consequences:
Safety Harm: Emotional harm to passed over applicants; reputational harm to company.
Ethical Damage: Breaking rules of justice, fairness and equal rights.
Mitigations:
The training data is diverse, and representative.
Independent AI Ethics Review Boards.
Ongoing Bias and Fairness Audits (in line with the BS 8611 Ethical Design Standard).
Employ Explainable AI (XAI) \ for trustworthy decisions
Why This Ethical Issue?
In it, bias represents the moral tension between technological advancement and human dignity — and so is the paramount ethical hurdle to display in AI-based recruitment.
Legal Issue — Data Protection &
Discrimination
Legal Area:
Privacy, Data Protection, and Equality Laws
Relevant Laws:
Legal Analysis:
Candidates have the right to human intervention in automated decision making under GDPR Article 22.
Equality Act 2010 guarantees equal opportunities; unfairly prejudiced results can lead to legal action.
If systems are not designed to enforce, you can have:
1) GDPR penalties up to €20 million or 4% of a company's annual
turnover.
2) Employment tribunals and reputational damage.
Mitigations:
Does an assessment before any deployment.
Adopt Privacy by Design principles.
Keep algorithmic accountability logs and transparency reports.
Have human supervision and appeals for candidates.
Why This Legal Issue?
Because it forms a direct bridge between ethics (bias) and law (liability, discrimination, privacy violation) — ethical harm to legal liability.
Professional Issue Accountability &
Transparency
Professional Area:
Professional Behaviour (ACM & BCS Codes of Conduct).
Relevant Code Sections:
Code Key Principles Application
Professional Reflection:
AI engineers must take responsibility for the effects of their systems.
Accountability must be part of the design, not a retrofit.
‘Black box’ models go against professional obligations of
transparency and explainability.
Mitigation Measures:
Keep track of every design choice and test—you never know when you’ll need to explain why you did something.
Bring in independent ethics boards, get your work peer reviewed.
Stay on top of new developments in AI ethics and law.
Why This Matters:
We’re not just building tech; we’re shaping what it means to be a responsible computing professional. Our job isn’t just to make things function—it’s to protect people.
Team Reflection
How We Worked
We divided things up:
one person tackled legal research, another dove into ethics, and someone else took charge of professional standards.
At first, we got hung up on “AI accuracy,” but once we started looking at the BCS and ACM codes, that changed.
We realized fairness—real fairness for people—matters more than just technical performance.
Ethical design isn’t some extra step. It’s what makes us real
professionals.
What We Learned:
Ethics, law, and professionalism? They’re all tied together. You can’t pull them apart. We left this project with a clearer idea of what accountability looks like. The law sets the floor, but true professionalism demands more.
THE END