Conformity and obedience slides final




Conformity and
Obedience

Prof. Charles Musslewhite FAcSS

Head of Psychology Department

Aberystwyth Uni

chm93@aber.ac.uk

1 / 27
volgende
Slide 1: Slide
newEditor

In deze les zitten 27 slides, met tekstslides.

Dit is niet oké

Onderdelen in deze les




Conformity and
Obedience

Prof. Charles Musslewhite FAcSS

Head of Psychology Department

Aberystwyth Uni

chm93@aber.ac.uk

Contents

Mere presence of others and social facilitation

  • Triplett (1898) and early research

    • Zajonc’s (1965) social facilitation model

    • Evaluation apprehension and performance effects


Conformity

  • Sherif (1935) – The Autokinetic Effect Study

    • Asch (1951) – Line Judgment Task


Obedience

  • Real life implications

    • Real-world examples (medical, aviation, maritime, nuclear)

  • Classic study

    • Milgram’s (1963) classic study and findings

    • Evaluation and ethical considerations


  • Extensions and Replications of Milgram

    • Hofling et al. (1966): Out of the lab

    • Burger (2009): Modern ethical replication


  • Modern Reinterpretations of Obedience

    • Haslam & Reicher (2012): Engaged followership model

    • Gibson (2013): Conversation analysis and persuasion

    • From blind obedience to active identification


Conclusions and Key Lessons


Mere presence of others

  • Triplett (1898) – cycle race, people cycled faster with the presence of others than they did v the clock

  • Repeated in laboratory experiment – children’s performance on a task better when another child was present performing the same task

  • But some studies showed performance can decrease

  • Zajonc (1965) social facilitation model

    • If task is easy or well rehearsed (dominant response to task is correct) then it is performed better (process gained)

    • If task is difficult or un –rehearsed (dominant response if incorrect) then it is performed worse

    • Bond and Titus (1983) looked at the results of over 200 studies using over 20,000 research participants and found that the presence of others did significantly increase the rate of performance on simple tasks and decrease both the rate and the quality of performance on complex tasks.

    • Zajonc reviewed evidence that dogs ran faster, chickens ate more feed, ants built bigger nests, when other dogs, chickens, and ants respectively, were around (Zajonc, 1965)

  • Just arousal? Maybe it is more about appraisal or evaluation? So we perform better when we perceive that the others are evaluating us or competing with us (Szymanski & Harkins, 1987).  Strube, Miles, & Finch, (1981) found that the presence of spectators increased the speed of joggers only when the spectators were facing the joggers and thus could see them and assess their performance.


Conformity – Changing Behaviour to Fit In

Definition:

  • Conformity is a change in behaviour or belief as a result of real or imagined group pressure.


Classic Studies:

• Sherif (1935): Autokinetic effect – estimates converged toward a group norm (informational social influence).

• Asch (1951): Line judgment task – participants conformed to wrong majority answers (normative social influence).


Kelman’s (1958) Types of Conformity:

• Compliance – outwardly agreeing, inwardly disagreeing (e.g., laughing at a joke you don’t find funny)

• Identification – adopting behaviour to fit a social role (e.g., joining a sports team and adopting its norms)

• Internalisation – genuine acceptance of group beliefs (e.g., changing personal views after discussion)


Conformity

  • 🧠 Sherif (1935) – The Autokinetic Effect Study

Aim: To investigate how people behave in ambiguous situations, and whether they use others as a source of information to guide their behaviour — what later became known as informational social influence.

Background

  • The autokinetic effect is a visual illusion: when a small, stationary point of light is viewed in a completely dark room, it appears to move — even though it doesn’t.

  • Because the movement is ambiguous (there’s no objective reference point), it provides an ideal setting to study how people form judgments when uncertain.

Method

  • Participants: Small groups (usually 3–4 people) of male students.

  • Procedure:

    • Phase 1 – Alone:
      Each participant sat in a dark room and estimated how far the light moved. Their estimates varied widely (e.g., 2–20 cm) because there was no real movement.

    • Phase 2 – In Groups:
      Participants were then placed in small groups and repeated the task aloud. Over several trials, their individual estimates converged toward a group norm.

    • Phase 3 – Alone Again:
      When tested alone later, participants’ estimates remained close to the group norm, suggesting internalisation of the shared judgment.

Results

  • Individual judgments converged to form a common group estimate.

  • Once established, the group norm influenced later individual responses — even when others were no longer present.


Conclusion

  • In uncertain or ambiguous situations, people look to others for guidance — showing informational social influence.

  • Conformity here occurs because people genuinely believe others are correct, not just to fit in.

  • The study demonstrated how group norms develop and persist over time.


Evaluation

  • ✅ Strengths:

  • Controlled lab setting — strong internal validity.

  • Pioneering study showing how social norms form and persist.

  • ❌ Limitations:

  • Artificial task (estimating light movement) — lacks ecological validity.

  • Participants may not have felt real social pressure — group conformity in real life is often more emotionally charged.


Key Takeaway

  • When people are uncertain, they turn to others for information —
    “If everyone else agrees, they must be right.”


Conformity

Asch (1951) – Line Judgment Task

  • Aim: To investigate whether people would conform to a majority opinion even when the correct answer is obvious — testing the power of normative social influence.

Background

  • Asch wanted to challenge Sherif’s (1935) findings.

  • Sherif used ambiguous situations, but Asch argued that true conformity involves yielding to group pressure when the correct answer is clear.

  • This allowed him to test whether individuals would go along with the majority to fit in rather than because they doubted their own judgment.

Method

  • Participants: 123 male American college students.

  • Procedure:

1.Participants were told they were taking part in a “visual perception” test.

2.They sat in a group of 6–8 people, where all but one were confederates of the experimenter.

3.Each person was shown a standard line and three comparison lines, and asked aloud which one matched in length.

4.The real participant always answered last or near last.

5.Confederates were instructed to give the same incorrect answer on 12 of 18 trials (the “critical trials”).


Conformity

Asch (1951) – Line Judgment Task: Results

  • On average, 37% of the critical trials showed conformity — participants agreed with the incorrect majority.

  • 75% of participants conformed at least once.

  • 25% never conformed at all.

  • In a control group (no confederates), less than 1% gave the wrong answer — proving the task itself was easy

  • Even in clear, unambiguous situations, people conform to group pressure to avoid standing out or being rejected.

  • This demonstrates normative social influence — the desire to be liked or accepted by the group.

  • Asch concluded that group consensus can distort individual judgment, even against obvious evidence.

Evaluation

✅ Strengths:

  • Controlled procedure — strong internal validity.

  • Demonstrated the powerful effect of social pressure in simple situations.

❌ Limitations:

  • Sample bias: All male, American students

  • Historical context: Conducted in 1950s America — a highly conformist culture (“McCarthyism”).

  • Artificial task: Judging line lengths has little real-world meaning — low ecological validity.

  • Ethical issues: Deception (participants misled about purpose).





Conformity

Conformity

  • Kelman (1958) – Types of Conformity

Aim: To explain the different levels and motivations behind conformity — recognising that not all conformity is the same or equally deep.

Background

  • Kelman argued that earlier research (e.g. Asch, Sherif) showed people conform for different reasons.

  • He proposed three distinct types of conformity, depending on how deeply a person’s attitudes or beliefs are affected by group influence.





Conformity

Conclusion

  • Conformity can be superficial or deep, depending on whether it changes public behaviour, private beliefs, or both.

  • Internalisation represents the strongest form of conformity, as attitudes are truly integrated into the self.

Evaluation

✅ Recognises psychological depth — not all conformity is the same.
✅ Explains why people might conform in different situations (temporary vs lasting change).
❌ Hard to measure — internal beliefs are not directly observable.
❌ Overlaps can occur between categories in real life.


Key Takeaway

Conformity can range from surface-level compliance to deep internal change.
The deeper the identification, the longer-lasting the conformity.


Conformity – Changing Behaviour to Fit In

Why We Conform:

• Normative influence – to be liked and accepted

• Informational influence – to be right or accurate

• Situational factors – group size, unanimity, task difficulty


Evaluation:

✓ Explains everyday behaviour (fashion, teamwork, social media)

✗ Laboratory studies may lack ecological validity

✗ Early research shows cultural and gender bias


Key Takeaway:

People conform for two main reasons: to be right (informational) and to be liked and accepted (normative).

Obedience

  • Example from Nigel:

  • In their book Medication Errors: Causes and Prevention, professors Michael Cohen and Neil Davis talk about a strange case of the “rectal earache”.

  • A physician ordered ear drops to be administered to the right ear of a patient suffering from pain and infection.

  • Instead of writing out completely “Right ear” on the prescription, the doctor abbreviated it, “place in R ear.”

  • The duty nurse misread “R ear” to be “Rear.” Upon receiving the prescription, she promptly put the required number of ear drops into the patient’s anus.

  • neither the patient nor the nurse questioned it. The important lesson of this story is that in many situations in which a legitimate authority figure has spoken, your common sense seems to become irrelevant.

  • Just following doctor’s orders.


Davis, N. M., & Cohen, M. R. (1981). Medication Errors: Causes and Prevention. G. F. Stickley Company.

Obedience

  • But can be much more serious

Tenerife Airport Disaster (1977)

  • What happened: Two Boeing 747s (KLM and Pan Am) collided on a foggy runway in the Canary Islands — killing 583 people, the deadliest aviation accident in history.

  • Hierarchy issue:

    • The KLM captain was highly senior and respected.

    • His first officer and flight engineer both had doubts about takeoff clearance but did not firmly challenge the captain’s decision to begin takeoff in poor visibility.

  • Outcome: Miscommunication with air traffic control and lack of assertiveness led to a fatal runway collision.

  • Lesson: Crew Resource Management (CRM) was developed afterwards to train pilots to speak up regardless of rank.


MS Estonia Ferry Disaster (1994)

What happened: The ferry sank in the Baltic Sea during rough weather; 852 people died.

Hierarchy issue:

Some reports suggest crew hesitated to question orders or raise concerns about water ingress until it was too late.

Lesson: Reinforced the importance of flat communication structures and safety reporting at sea.


Costa Concordia (2012)

What happened: The cruise ship ran aground off Italy; 32 deaths.

Hierarchy issue:

The captain’s reckless decision to sail close to shore went unchallenged by subordinates.

Crew members later reported being afraid to contradict or question the captain’s authority.

Lesson: Even modern maritime operations can suffer when hierarchy discourages speaking up.


Obedience

☢️ Chernobyl Disaster (Ukraine, 1986) – just a word of caution

Summary:

  • During a late-night safety test at Reactor 4, engineers conducted a turbine rundown experiment that spiraled out of control.

  • The reactor exploded, causing the worst nuclear accident in history — massive radioactive release, long-term deaths, and displacement.

Hierarchy/Authority Issues:

  • Operators obeyed unsafe orders from senior engineers even though they knew the conditions were dangerous.

  • The shift leader and control room staff hesitated to question or stop the test, despite multiple warning signs.

  • The deputy chief engineer (Dyatlov) pressured subordinates to continue, reportedly shouting and intimidating those who expressed concern.

  • The Soviet system fostered a culture where disobedience or questioning authority was unacceptable.

Lesson:

  • Hierarchical pressure and fear of contradiction can silence critical safety input — especially in rigid, top-down organizations.

  • Dyatlov recovered from radiation poison and was jailed for 10 years. He claims his innocence in only having a partial contribution. The reactor had 30 severe faults. “The reactor didn’t comply with more than 30 standard design requirements” – Scapegoating?




Obedience



  • The one we all know!?

  • Milgram, S (1974). Obedience to authority. New York: Harper & Row

Obedience

Aim To investigate how far ordinary people would obey orders from an authority figure, even if it meant harming another person.


Method

  • Participants: 40 men aged 20–50, from various occupations and educational backgrounds, recruited through a newspaper advertisement. Paid $4.50 for participation.

  • Setting: Yale University laboratory.

  • Design: Controlled observation (often described as a lab experiment, though no true independent variable).

  • Procedure:

    • Participant (always the teacher) believed they were taking part in a memory experiment with another man (the learner, a confederate).

    • The learner was strapped to a chair and attached to what appeared to be an electric shock generator.

    • The teacher was told to administer a shock each time the learner gave a wrong answer, increasing the voltage from 15V to 450V.

    • At 150V the learner protested; at 300V refused to answer; after 315V became silent.

    • The experimenter (wearing a lab coat) used standardised prods if the teacher hesitated, e.g. “The experiment requires that you continue.”

    • No real shocks were given — the learner’s responses were pre-recorded.

    • After the session, participants were debriefed and told the true purpose of the study.


Findings

  • 65% of participants administered the maximum 450 volts.

  • All went up to at least 300 volts.

  • Participants often showed stress and conflict, e.g. sweating, trembling, stuttering, and nervous laughter.

  • Many expressed relief afterwards but were surprised by how far they had gone.


Conclusions

  • Milgram concluded that situational factors, rather than personality, largely determine obedience.
    Ordinary people are likely to follow orders from an authority figure even when this results in harming another person, due to the agentic state — acting as an agent for someone else’s wishes and feeling less personal responsibility.



Obedience

  • Milgram’s Own Variations (1963–1974)

Milgram himself carried out 18 variations of his original study to explore situational factors affecting obedience.


Conclusion: Changes in situation (authority proximity, setting, perceived legitimacy) strongly affect obedience — supporting Milgram’s situational explanation.





Milgram adaptations

Obedience

Evaluation of Milgram’s original study

Strengths

  • High control — Laboratory conditions allowed careful standardisation (same prods, same setting), giving strong internal validity.

  • Practical and theoretical importance — Showed that ordinary people can commit harmful acts under authority pressure, challenging “Germans are different” explanations of Nazi atrocities.

  • Follow-up studies — Replications (e.g. in other countries and variations by Milgram himself) found similar results, suggesting the findings are reliable.


Weaknesses

  • Ethical issues:

    • Deception: Participants were misled about the true purpose and believed they were giving real shocks.

    • Lack of informed consent: They didn’t know the real aims beforehand.

    • Psychological distress: Many showed severe emotional tension.

    • Right to withdraw: Although technically allowed, the experimenter’s “prods” made it feel as though withdrawal wasn’t possible.

  • Ecological validity: The situation (electric shocks in a lab) was artificial and unlikely to represent real-life obedience scenarios.

  • Sample bias: Only American men were used — limits population validity and generalisation to women or non-Western cultures. Women were participants in a later study (65% conformity)

  • Legacy and Impact

  • Milgram’s work has had a profound and lasting influence on psychology and society:

  • Understanding authority and obedience:
    It reshaped thinking about why people obey authority — relevant to soldiers, police, workplaces, and institutions.

  • Ethics in psychological research:
    The controversy over deception and distress led to stricter ethical guidelines for psychological experiments (e.g. informed consent, debriefing, right to withdraw).

  • Applications to real-world events:
    Findings have been used to explain historical atrocities (e.g. the Holocaust) and later events (e.g. Abu Ghraib prison abuses), showing how social context and authority can override morals.

  • Further research:
    Inspired later studies — such as Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison Experiment (1971) and Burger’s partial replication (2009) — exploring obedience and social influence with greater ethical safeguards.

  • Public awareness:
    The study remains one of the most famous in psychology, sparking enduring debate about human nature, morality, and the power of authority.

Obedience

Hofling et al. (1966) – Obedience in a Hospital Setting

Aim: To test whether nurses would obey an instruction from a doctor that went against both hospital rules and their professional judgment — a real-world test of obedience to authority in a naturalistic setting.

Method

Participants: 22 real nurses working in hospitals in the USA.

Design: Field experiment (natural setting, high ecological validity).

Procedure:

  • Each nurse received a telephone call from an unfamiliar “doctor” (a male confederate).

    • The “doctor” instructed the nurse to administer 20 mg of a fictional drug called “Astroten” to a specific patient.

    • The label on the drug bottle clearly stated that the maximum safe dose was 10 mg and that instructions should not be accepted by phone — both explicit hospital rules.

    • Observers recorded whether the nurse would prepare or actually attempt to give the medication before being stopped and debriefed.

Results

  • 21 out of 22 nurses (95%) began to comply with the order — preparing or starting to administer the drug.

  • A control group of 21 nurses (asked hypothetically what they would do) overwhelmingly said they would refuse.

  • This demonstrates the power of authority (the perceived status of “doctor”) over individual judgment, even among trained professionals.

  • Conclusion

  • Obedience to authority is not confined to artificial lab settings like Milgram’s.

  • Even in real-world, professional environments, authority figures can override moral or procedural rules.

  • Highlights the danger of unquestioning obedience in hierarchical institutions such as hospitals, militaries, or bureaucracies.


Evaluation

  • ✅ Strengths:

  • High ecological validity — natural setting and real authority structures.

  • Supports Milgram’s findings in a different context.
    ❌ Limitations:

  • Ethical concerns (nurses deceived without consent).

  • Lack of informed consent — though participants were debriefed later.

  • Conducted only in one type of institution (hospitals) and in 1960s America — may not generalise across time or professions.


Hofling, C. K., Brotzman, E., Dalrymple, S., Graves, N., & Pierce, C. M. (1966). An experimental study in nurse–physician relationships. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 143(2), 171–180.





Obedience

Burger (2009) – Ethical Partial Replication of Milgram

Aim: To replicate Milgram’s procedure ethically and test whether levels of obedience have changed over time (nearly 50 years later).

Method

  • Participants: 70 adults (29 men, 41 women), aged 20–81, recruited through adverts in California.

  • Screening: Rigorous screening to exclude individuals with psychological vulnerabilities or who might experience distress.

  • Design: Laboratory study closely modelled on Milgram’s, but with modern ethical safeguards.


Procedure changes:

  • The maximum voltage was stopped at 150V (the point at which Milgram’s participants first heard serious protests from the learner — “heart condition, let me out!”).

    • Participants were told they could withdraw at any time and still receive their payment.

    • Two experimenters monitored participants for distress and stopped the experiment if needed.

    • After debriefing, participants met the “learner” to confirm no harm occurred.


Results

  • 70% of participants were willing to continue past 150 volts (comparable to Milgram’s 82.5% reaching that same point).

  • No significant difference between men and women.

  • Participants who stopped earlier tended to express stronger personal responsibility or less trust in the experimenter’s authority.


Conclusion

  • Obedience levels remain high, even decades later, suggesting Milgram’s findings are not bound to his era or cultural moment.

  • Ethical adjustments did not significantly reduce obedience, showing that situational pressures to obey authority remain powerful.


Evaluation

  • ✅ Strengths:

  • Ethically sound — modern consent and debriefing procedures.

  • High reliability — closely replicated Milgram’s structure with consistent results.
    ❌ Limitations:

  • Because it stopped at 150V, we can’t know how many would have gone to 450V.

  • Still a lab study — not fully reflective of real-world obedience.

Burger, J. M. (2009). Replicating Milgram: Would people still obey today? American Psychologist, 64(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0010932

Obedience

  • Haslam & Reicher (2012) and Gibson (2013) – Reinterpretations

  • Both studies re-analysed Milgram’s findings conceptually, arguing that obedience isn’t just blind conformity, but involves active identification and persuasion.


Haslam & Reicher (2012): “Engaged Followership” Model

  • Core Argument: People obey not because they lose autonomy (as Milgram suggested with the “agentic state”) but because they believe in the authority’s goals.

  • Participants act as “engaged followers” — identifying with the scientific purpose (“for the advancement of knowledge”) and viewing disobedience as letting down the cause.




Evidence

  • Analysis of Milgram’s transcripts revealed that participants who continued to obey often spoke positively about helping science or trusted the experimenter’s justification.

  • When experimenters used prods appealing to authority (“You must continue”), obedience decreased; when they used appeals to purpose (“The experiment requires it”), obedience increased.

Conclusion

  • Obedience is motivated by shared identity and moral alignment, not just submission or fear.

  • This model reframes obedience as a social process of identification, rather than passive compliance.




Haslam, S. A., & Reicher, S. D. (2012). Contesting the “nature” of conformity: What Milgram and Zimbardo’s studies really show. PLoS Biology, 10(11), e1001426.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.1001426

Obedience

Gibson (2013): Conversation Analysis

Approach Gibson used conversation analysis of Milgram’s original recordings to study how experimenter–participant interactions unfolded moment by moment.

  • Found that the experimenter’s prods were more like persuasion or negotiation, not simple commands.


Findings

  • Participants often questioned or resisted the experimenter.

  • Experimenters adjusted their responses, trying to convince rather than coerce participants.

  • This suggests participants were actively reasoning rather than blindly obeying.




Conclusion

  • Obedience in Milgram’s studies may have been less absolute and more interactional than traditionally portrayed.

  • Gibson challenges the idea of the “agentic shift”, instead highlighting communication, justification, and participant agency.


Combined Impact (Haslam & Reicher, Gibson)

  • Modern reinterpretations suggest obedience is complex, social, and context-driven.

  • People obey when they identify with the authority’s mission — not merely when authority exerts power.

  • This view integrates social identity theory with obedience research, providing a richer, less pessimistic view of human behaviour than Milgram’s original model.


Gibson, S. (2013). Milgram’s obedience experiments: A rhetorical analysis. British Journal of Social Psychology, 52(2), 290–309.https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8309.2011.02070.x





Obedience beyond Milgram overview

Conclusions

  • Social influence is powerful — it shapes behaviour across settings evidence from labs to application in workplaces.

  • Human (and animal) performance is socially shaped — we’re motivated, and sometimes pressured, by the awareness of others.

  • Conformity occurs when people adjust their behaviour or beliefs to align with group norms, driven by the desire to be liked or accepted (normative influence) or to be right (informational influence).

  • The depth of conformity varies — from superficial compliance to lasting internalisation, depending on personal identification with the group and the situation’s ambiguity.

  • Compliance techniques rely on social norms (reciprocity, consistency, guilt, self-image) and can be powerful — but unethical use risks loss of trust and retaliation.

  • Obedience is a deeply rooted social process — necessary for order, but dangerous when it silences moral judgment or critical thinking.

  • Modern Interpretation of obedience:

    • Obedience is not blind; it often stems from shared belief or identification with an authority’s mission (e.g. “for science,” “for safety”).

    • People reason, negotiate, and resist — showing agency, not simple passivity.

    • This reframes Milgram’s pessimistic view into a more complex, social understanding of obedience.