Hunting, Not Fishing
Hunting, Not Fishing
Open by framing the session around responsive teaching: noticing misconceptions as they appear and acting on them precisely, rather than asking broad questions and hoping understanding emerges.
Learning goal
I can use Lemov’s ‘Hunting, Not Fishing’ to spot and tackle misconceptions in the moment.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
When do misconceptions usually surface in your English lessons?
Use this to surface staff habits and contexts: class discussion, written responses, questioning, annotations, mini whiteboards, exit tickets. Pick out whether answers focus on volunteers or whole-class evidence.
What does ‘Hunting, Not Fishing’ mean?
‘Fishing’ is asking broad, open classroom questions and waiting to see what comes back.
‘Hunting’ is checking for a specific idea, likely error, or misconception.
The shift is from general participation to precise evidence of thinking.
Make clear that this is not about making questioning rigid; it is about making checking purposeful. Staff often confuse high participation with secure understanding.
Why precision matters
Pupils can appear fluent while holding insecure ideas
Misconceptions become harder to shift if left unchallenged
Immediate correction supports accurate memory and future learning
Anchor this in evidence-informed teaching: retrieval is strengthened when errors are corrected before they become embedded. Link to formative assessment and responsive teaching rather than presenting it as a stand-alone technique.
What research suggests
Responsive teaching works best when teachers gather actionable evidence during learning.
Whole-class checks, cold call, mini whiteboards, and tightly designed questions help reveal thinking that would otherwise stay hidden.
The key principle from evidence-informed practice is simple: check what pupils think, not just whether they speak.
You can reference the wider evidence base around formative assessment, checking for understanding, and reducing the gap between teaching and pupil thinking. Keep the claims cautious and practical.
Fishing vs hunting in practice
Fishing
‘Does everyone get it?’
‘Any questions?’
One pupil answers for the room
Confidence is mistaken for understanding
Hunting
‘What does the comma do in this sentence?’
‘Which line shows Macbeth’s ambition?’
Every pupil is checked against one clear point
Errors are surfaced early
Because this is English-focused staff development, keep examples rooted in classroom interpretation, grammar, and text analysis rather than generic questioning alone.
Start with the likely misconception
Before asking a question, identify the most probable error.
In English, this might be:
confusing quotation with analysis
retelling the plot instead of interpreting language
spotting a device without explaining its effect
Good hunting begins with predicting where thinking may go wrong.
This is the planning hinge. Emphasise that strong teachers anticipate errors from prior assessments, classwork, and curriculum knowledge, not from guesswork.
What is the key shift in ‘Hunting, Not Fishing’?
General participation
Precise evidence
Longer discussion
More volunteers
This checks the core contrast from slides 2–5: hunting is about precise evidence of thinking, not simply getting more pupils to speak.
Complete the summary
In Lemov’s terms, fishing means asking broad questions and waiting to see what comes back. hunting checks for a specific idea or likely error. Strong teachers begin by predicting the most likely misconception before they ask the question.
All three blanks are load-bearing terms from the first teaching block.
What likely misconception would you plan for in this task?
Expected answer elements: staff should identify a probable error such as plot retelling instead of analysis, naming a device without effect, or confusing quotation with analysis. Invite one concrete example from English.
Design questions that expose thinking
Ask for one precise idea at a time
Use examples that force a choice or explanation
Check all pupils, not only volunteers
Listen for the error beneath the answer
You may want to model the difference between a vague question such as ‘What do we learn about the character?’ and a hunting question such as ‘Which word in the line suggests secrecy, and how?’
In-the-moment response
When a misconception appears:
name the error clearly
restate the accurate idea
recheck with the class
repeat if needed with a tighter example
The aim is not to move on quickly; it is to secure the idea before it hardens.
This slide turns diagnosis into action. Staff sometimes identify a misconception but then accept a corrected answer from one pupil and move on. Stress the need to recheck the whole class.
Case study: analysing a quotation
A Year 10 class is discussing a line from Macbeth.
Teacher asks: ‘What does this quotation show?’
One pupil gives a confident plot summary.
Several nod, but written responses reveal pupils are retelling events rather than analysing language.
The original question checked participation, not understanding.
Use this as a familiar secondary English example. The issue is not the pupil speaking incorrectly alone; it is that the question allowed an imprecise form of success.
Case study: hunting instead
A tighter sequence might be:
‘Which single word in the quotation suggests ambition?’
‘What does that word imply?’
‘Is that plot summary or language analysis?’
‘Everyone write one analytical sentence using that word.’
This surfaces the misconception and corrects it immediately.
Highlight the move from broad interpretation to a narrow, evidence-based check. The final written sentence is especially useful because it verifies whether correction has transferred beyond talk.
Scenario: punctuation misconception
Contrast a comma and semicolon in two model sentences
Ask which punctuation joins closely linked main clauses
Recheck with all pupils
Have pupils correct the original statement
Hunting response
A pupil says a semicolon is ‘just a posh comma’.
Others copy the idea into their notes.
The misconception is now spreading through the room.
What happens
This example helps show that Hunting, Not Fishing applies beyond literature discussion. It works in grammar, writing, and reading equally well.
After naming a misconception, what should happen next?
Move on quickly
Ask volunteers only
Recheck the class
Set homework only
Targets the sequence on slide 8: name, restate, recheck, repeat. Distractors reflect common pitfalls.
Complete the response routine
When a misconception appears, the teacher should name the error clearly, restate the accurate idea, then recheck with the class. If needed, repeat with a tighter example.
This secures the in-the-moment response sequence before the case study and punctuation scenario are discussed further.
How would you tackle ‘A semicolon is just a posh comma’?
Expected answer elements: compare comma and semicolon with model sentences, ask which joins closely linked main clauses, recheck all pupils, and have them correct the original claim. Look for precision and whole-class checking.
Scenario: weak inference
Pupils can often infer, but not support the inference with evidence.
A hunting move is to separate the steps:
find the word or phrase
name the inference
explain the link
This prevents unsupported guesswork from sounding secure.
Useful phrase for staff: do not accept a right answer with wrong reasoning. Hunting checks the process behind the answer.
Common pitfalls
asking a better question but only to one pupil
correcting the answer without explaining the misconception
moving on after one secure response
overloading the moment with too many corrections at once
treating silence as understanding
Point out that pace can create these errors. Staff may feel pressure to keep the lesson moving, but precision now saves reteaching later.
What effective practice sounds like
Useful teacher language is direct and specific:
‘That is a plot point; I need analysis.’
‘You have named the device. Now explain its effect.’
‘Let’s check whether everyone has that idea accurately.’
‘Try again using the evidence in the line.’
Model calm, neutral correction. The tone matters: pupils should experience misconception as normal and correctable, not as failure.
Planning for tomorrow’s lesson
Build hunting into planning by deciding:
the exact idea pupils must grasp
the likely misconception
the question that will reveal it
the response if the misconception appears
This makes in-the-moment correction quicker and sharper.
End the main content with practical transfer. Staff should leave with a planning routine, not just a concept.
Which response best fits weak inference?
Accept the inference
Ask for feelings
Separate the steps
Praise the guess
Checks slide 12: find the word or phrase, name the inference, explain the link.
Complete the planning routine
Build hunting into planning by deciding the exact idea pupils must grasp, the likely misconception, the question that will reveal it, and the response if it appears.
Echoes the final planning slide and helps staff leave with a usable routine.
Which pitfall is easiest to slip into under time pressure?
One secure response
One pupil only
Too many corrections
Silence as understanding
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
What is one thing you will use in tomorrow’s lesson?
Reflection prompt only. Invite a concrete strategy, routine, or teacher phrase they will use next lesson.
Which part of this approach still feels hardest?
Reflection prompt only. Encourage honest responses about planning, rechecking, or identifying likely misconceptions.
Glossary
Hunting, Not Fishing - A questioning approach that checks for a specific piece of understanding or a likely misconception.
misconception - An incorrect or insecure idea that affects understanding.
responsive teaching - Adapting teaching in real time based on evidence of pupil thinking.
check for understanding - A deliberate method for finding out what pupils know, think, or misunderstand.
cold call - Selecting pupils to respond without relying on volunteers.
formative assessment - Gathering evidence during learning so teaching can respond and improve understanding.
language analysis - Explaining how a writer’s word choices create meaning or effect.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies