Writing a Review: And Then There Were None
Writing a Review: And Then There Were None
Today's Lesson Program
1. What do you already know?
2. Exploring a critical review
3. Identifying key structures in a review
Write your own review
Reflecting / feedback
End of lesson
What do you already know about writing a book review?
minute
second
Learning Objective
At the end of the lesson you will be able to write a critical 240–280-word review in English for the publisher of 'And Then There Were None' by Agatha Christie.
Meet Agatha Christie
Agatha Christie is known as the 'Queen of Crime'. She wrote over 70 detective novels and created famous detectives as Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple.
1. Offensive Original Title: Published in 1939 as "Ten Little N*ggers" in the UK (using a racist slur from a nursery rhyme). The US used "And Then There Were None" immediately. The UK didn't change it until the 1980s—reflecting unchallenged 1930s racism.
2. Her Hardest Book to Write
Christie called it her most difficult novel. The challenge: killing all ten characters while maintaining suspense and fair play. Each death required meticulous planning, every character had to seem plausibly guilty at different points, and the solution needed to be both surprising and logical.
3. Manuscript Nearly Lost in WWII
Written partly at her Greenway Estate in Devon. After publication, her London publisher's offices were bombed during the Blitz, risking parts of her archive—though this manuscript survived.
4. Stage Version Got a Happy Ending
Christie's 1943 stage adaptation completely changed the ending—two characters survive. Wartime audiences needed hope. She resisted initially but the play became one of the longest-running in West End history. She later admitted the theatrical ending worked better on stage.
5. Burgh Island Inspired the Setting
The isolated Burgh Island Hotel in Devon (accessible only at low tide) inspired Soldier Island. Christie stayed there multiple times in the 1930s, absorbing the claustrophobic atmosphere, Art Deco design, and dramatic tidal causeway.
Bonus: Christie wrote this during personal turmoil after her first marriage ended. The novel's bleakness and exploration of guilt may reflect her processing of betrayal and moral complexity.
About 'And Then There Were None'
This novel is a classic murder mystery where ten strangers are invited to an isolated island and mysterious events follow. It explores themes of justice and guilt.
What is a Book Review?
Purpose
A book review is a critical evaluation of a book, discussing its strengths, weaknesses and overall impact.
Definition
Reviews help readers decide if they should read a book and give feedback to the publisher and author.
Key Elements of an Effective Review
1. Brief summary (no spoilers) 2. Discussion of main themes and style 3. Your opinion, supported with examples 4. Recommendation
Structure of a Review
A. Introduction: Book details & context B. Body: Analysis and evaluation C. Conclusion: Personal judgement & recommendation
Useful Language for Reviews
- The novel explores... - The plot is... - Christie's writing style is... - I found the character development... - I would recommend this book to...
What Makes a Review Critical?
A critical review does not mean negative – it means thoughtful, analytical and balanced. Use evidence from the book to support your views.
Tips for Avoiding Spoilers
Describe major themes and your opinion without revealing key plot twists or the ending. Focus on what makes the book interesting.
Sample Sentence Starters
Giving Your Opinion
In my opinion, the novel’s strongest aspect is...
‘And Then There Were None’ by Agatha Christie is...
Introducing the Book
Analysing a Sample Review
Let's read a sample review. Spot the summary, opinion, analysis and recommendation parts.
minute
second
Planning Your Review
1. Make notes about the plot, characters, themes and your overall impression. 2. Consider what you’d recommend and to whom.
Writing Time: Your Review
- Clear structure - Analytical points - Supporting examples - No major spoilers
Write a 240–280 word critical review of 'And Then There Were None' in English for the publisher.
Task
Checklist
minute
second
Reflection:
What did you find challenging about writing a review? What techniques helped you the most?
minute
second
Write down 3 things you learned in this lesson.
Write down 2 things you want to know more about.
Ask 1 question about something you haven't quite understood yet.