Dilemma + utilisme

Utilitarianism

In the moral assessment of an action, only the consequences of an action count.

1 / 13
volgende
Slide 1: Slide
newEditorLevensbeschouwingMiddelbare schoolhavo, vwoLeerjaar 4,5

In deze les zitten 13 slides, met interactieve quizzen en tekstslides.

time-iconLesduur is: 50 min
Dit is niet oké

Onderdelen in deze les

Utilitarianism

In the moral assessment of an action, only the consequences of an action count.

After this lesson

- explain in your own words what utilitarianism is and how it can help with ethical issues.

How do you determine what the right thing to do is?

Ethical theories - help to determine what is right.


We cover three theories:

utilitarianism

deontological ethics - principle ethics

virtue ethics

What do you think the word 'utilitarianism' means?

A

meaning

B

purpose

C

moral conduct

D

useful

Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832)

Utility equals pleasant experiences and suffering in the absence of utility.

Animals can also suffer, so they should be considered in the judgement. 

Protested against: idiotic criminal law (e.g. death penalty for inappropriate behaviour between a man and a woman in bed).

Ridiculous: someone was punished for an act that harmed no one. 

Moral basic rule: an act should be morally judged based on whether it increases or decreases the happiness of those whose interest is involved. 

Happiness and well-being are indeed important.


Peter Singer


Most well-known utilitarian thinker. 

What is good? You must avert suffering. It is important to act in such a way that as many people and animals as possible suffer as little as possible.


Poverty

All people: the right to a dignified existence.

If you are wealthy: you have the moral duty to save the very poorest: so it's not optional. 

Humaneness is the most important thing in life!

Statement 1: it is wrong if someone dies unnecessarily or prematurely due to food shortages.

Statement 2: If it is within our power to prevent something bad: then we must help.

Statement 3: Every person is equal: people have the same rights.

If you do nothing: then you are negligent.

Casus

As an engineer, you are involved in research on a new pesticide. Based on a risk analysis, you discover that if this pesticide were used on a large scale in developing country X, 200 people with a hypersensitivity to this substance would die each year. However, the harvest would increase to such an extent that 10,000 fewer people would die of hunger each year. Do you think developing country X should use this pesticide? What would someone from a utilitarian perspective answer?


Criticism?


1. Balance of happiness: does that mean a group can be unhappy? The minority.

2. There is only one measure: happiness. Does every degree of happiness weigh the same?

3. Does the end justify the means? Can you do anything to achieve your goal?


Can a 'white lie' be permissible according to utilitarianism?


A

Yes, as long as by lying you increase the total happiness in the world.

B

No, lying is always wrong even if your motive is right.

Make assignment 14 tm 18