MSc MANAGEMENT • ECONOMICS
BRITISH AIRWAYS
Economics of Markets, Competition & Strategy
A long-haul passenger market case study
JFK
LONDON — NEW YORK
Transatlantic
HND
LONDON — TOKYO
Asia-Pacific
HKG
LONDON — HONG KONG
Asia-Pacific
Research question: How does BA balance fares, competition and costs?
MSc MANAGEMENT • ECONOMICS
BRITISH AIRWAYS
Economics of Markets, Competition & Strategy
A long-haul passenger market case study
JFK
LONDON — NEW YORK
Transatlantic
HND
LONDON — TOKYO
Asia-Pacific
HKG
LONDON — HONG KONG
Asia-Pacific
Research question: How does BA balance fares, competition and costs?
01 / MARKET STRUCTURE
A differentiated oligopoly
02
WHY THE MARKET IS DIFFERENTIATED
Few major players
• Large airlines dominate many long-haul routes
• Entry requires significant capital
Different products
• Schedules, cabins and baggage rules vary
• Loyalty and connections matter
Strategic reactions
• Fare changes invite competitor responses
• Capacity choices affect rivals
CORE THEORY
Oligopoly + strategic interdependence
Key insight: define competition at route level — pressure is not identical everywhere.
02 / ROUTE CASE STUDIES
Three routes, three competitive lenses
03
01
LONDON → NEW YORK
American Airlines
Fares • frequency • transatlantic cooperation
02
LONDON → TOKYO
All Nippon Airways (ANA)
Fares • schedules • service experience
03
LONDON → HONG KONG
Cathay Pacific
Premium cabins • connectivity • business travel
Compare like with like: same dates, cabin, baggage and fare flexibility.
03 / MICROECONOMIC DRIVERS
Demand, supply and price elasticity
04
DEMAND
• Income and travel budgets
• Seasonality and booking time
• Business or leisure purpose
• Prices and substitute airlines
SUPPLY
• Aircraft and seat capacity
• Airport slots and frequency
• Staffing and maintenance
• Fuel and operating costs
ELASTICITY
• Elastic: quantity reacts strongly to price
• Inelastic: quantity reacts less
• Flexibility and alternatives matter
• Segment behaviour; don't stereotype
Price elasticity = % change in quantity demanded ÷ % change in price
04 / PRICING & PROFITABILITY
Pricing is a revenue-management problem
05
DEMAND
Forecast bookings
→
FARES
Manage fare classes
→
CAPACITY
Protect seat inventory
→
RESULT
Maximise contribution
COST BASE
• Aircraft, fuel, staff, maintenance
• Airport, distribution and service costs
ECONOMIC LOGIC
• Seats perish at departure
• Extra booking helps if revenue exceeds incremental cost
A full aircraft is not automatically a profitable flight.
05 / EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
PESTEL: external forces shape the economics
06
P
POLITICAL
Airspace restrictions • geopolitical risk
E
ECONOMIC
Fuel • inflation • income • exchange rates
S
SOCIAL
Tourism trends • preferences • travel habits
T
TECHNOLOGICAL
Efficient aircraft • digital booking • analytics
E
ENVIRONMENTAL
Emissions • carbon costs • sustainable fuel
L
LEGAL
Safety • passenger rights • competition law
Prioritise the external factors with the greatest impact on each route.
06 / INDUSTRY ATTRACTIVENESS
Porter's Five Forces
07
RIVALRY
HIGH
Fares • schedules • service
NEW ENTRANTS
LOW–MED
Capital • regulation • slots
BUYER POWER
MED–HIGH
Fare comparison • switching
SUPPLIERS
HIGH
Aircraft • engines • airports
SUBSTITUTES
MEDIUM
Other airlines • video meetings
Force ratings are qualitative hypotheses — test them against route-level evidence.
07 / ROUTE-LEVEL ANALYSIS
Competitor comparison: collect comparable evidence
08
ROUTE
COMPARISON
MEASURE
London–New York
American Airlines
Fare • frequency • schedule • cooperation
London–Tokyo
ANA
Fare • cabin • service • journey time
London–Hong Kong
Cathay Pacific
Fare • premium cabin • connectivity
Control the comparison: dates • cabin • baggage • flexibility • observation date
A lower fare alone does not prove greater efficiency or profitability.
08 / ENTRY BARRIERS
Barriers to entry protect position — not profit
09
01
Capital-intensive aircraft and operations
02
Scarce airport slots, especially at Heathrow
03
Safety approvals and regulatory compliance
04
Brand trust, loyalty and network connections
05
Fuel and operating-cost volatility
IMPORTANT DISTINCTION
Starting an airline ≠ adding one route
An established carrier may enter a route more easily than a new airline can build a whole network.
09 / RECOMMENDATIONS
Conclusion: compete on value, manage the economics
10
WHAT THE ANALYSIS SUGGESTS
• BA operates in a capital-intensive, differentiated market
• Demand sensitivity and rivalry vary by route
• Supplier costs and capacity constrain profitability
• Ticket price alone is not a profitability measure
RECOMMENDED ACTIONS
01
Refine data-driven revenue management
02
Improve reliability and operating efficiency
03
Differentiate through service, convenience and loyalty
04
Evaluate capacity and fares route by route
Profitability = the right fare + the right passenger mix + disciplined costs
APPENDIX / BEFORE PRESENTING
Sources and evidence checklist
11
British Airways
Transatlantic joint business information
britishairways.com
ANA
London–Tokyo route information
flights.ana.co.jp
Cathay Pacific
London–Hong Kong route information
flights.cathaypacific.com
IAG
Annual reports and financial information
iairgroup.com
UK Competition and Markets Authority
Atlantic Joint Business Agreement investigation
gov.uk/cma-cases
Record observation date, cabin, fare rules and source for every price or frequency claim.