Higher English
Unit
Reading for Analysis and Evaluation
Higher English
Unit
Reading for Analysis and Evaluation
Contents
The Big Picture
Learning Intentions
Word Choice
Figures of Speech
Sentence Structure
Tone
Other Types of Questions
Evaluation Questions
The Big Picture
There is no mystery about how to perform well in the Reading for Understanding, Analysis and Evaluation paper!
There are only certain things which you can be asked about and it is your job to learn exactly how to answer each of the different types of questions.
This is the one and only time where English becomes like Maths! You are almost ‘learning the formula’ for answering different types of questions.
As we progress through this unit you should continue to add notes to your Learning Log whenever you see this symbol:
Learning Intentions
I will reach a clearer understanding of how to answer the different types of analysis and evaluation questions in this paper.
I will have the opportunity to practise answering a range of these questions.
I will be familiar with the words used in different analysis and evaluation questions because this will help me decide how to answer the questions.
Word Choice
This is About…
Worked Example
In a world changing faster now than ever before, the dispossessed and the ambitious are flooding into cities swollen out of all recognition. Poor cities are struggling to cope. Rich cities are reconfiguring themselves at breakneck speed. China has created an industrial powerhouse from what were fishing villages in the 1970s. Lagos and Dhaka attract a thousand new arrivals every day. In Britain, central London’s population has started to grow again after 50 years of decline.
Show how any two examples of word choice in this paragraph emphasise the impact of the growth of cities. 2 marks
In a world changing faster now than ever before, the dispossessed and the ambitious are flooding into cities swollen out of all recognition. Poor cities are struggling to cope. Rich cities are reconfiguring themselves at breakneck speed. China has created an industrial powerhouse from what were fishing villages in the 1970s. Lagos and Dhaka attract a thousand new arrivals every day. In Britain, central London’s population has started to grow again after 50 years of decline.
You can see from reading this paragraph that the impact of growth on cities is not a positive one.
Therefore, you are looking for words with negative connotations.
You must then choose 2 examples and – as you do with every word choice question – comment on the connotations of the words.
Worked Example-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment on the chosen words. For full marks, two examples must be dealt with. Reference alone: 0.
Possible answers:
1 “flooding into” suggests a force which is powerful, massive, unstoppable, out of control, coming at great speed, impossible to contain,
2 “swollen” suggests something bloated, unnatural, disfigured, …
3 “out of all recognition” suggests essential nature of the cities has been massively altered, ruined, compromised, …
4 “struggling (to cope)” suggests dealing with this influx is difficult, challenging, a battle, …
5 “reconfiguring” suggests fundamental change
6 “at breakneck speed” suggests speed of change involved is reckless, dangerously fast, likely to lead to disaster, …
7 “(industrial) powerhouse” suggests something very forceful, strong, energetic has been created (“powerful” alone: 0) or suggests something which will make a great impact on, influence, benefit, dominate its surroundings
Over to You!
You are now going to use what you have been learning to answer a range of different word choice questions.
Each question is followed by the SQA answer and you should compare this with what you have written.
Question 1
I would even extend the argument to the shopping mall—the quintessential expression of the alleged degradation of shopping. Hong Kong proclaims itself the shopping capital of the world; its malls are marble-floored temples to consumption that make their British counterparts look tawdry. But instead of recoiling from the excess, I found it attractive. The effort made to present the goods well is an act of creativity in its own right. The collective impact throbs with vitality.
Show how the writer’s word choice in these lines conveys his admiration for shopping malls in Hong Kong. 2 marks
Q1-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment will be worth 2 marks; more basic comments will be worth up to 1 mark each. Reference alone: 0. 2A
Possible answers:
“marble-floored” suggests opulence, wealth, beauty, quality, luxury
2. “temples” suggests the malls are places of deep, almost spiritual significance, places where shopping equates with worship and devotion
3. “attractive” suggests they are pleasing, charming, alluring
4. “creativity” suggests they are inventive, original, expressive, dynamic places
5. “impact” suggests they make a powerful, almost physical impression
6. “throbs” suggests their pounding, pulsating, invigorating nature
7. “vitality” suggests their vigour, energy
Question 2
Reading books enriches the mind; playing video games deadens it—you can’t get much more conventional than the conventional wisdom that kids today would be better off spending more time reading books, and less time zoning out in front of their video games.
Show how the writer’s word choice in these lines emphasises the “conventional wisdom” that reading books is better than playing video games. 2 marks
Q2-Answer
Possible answers:
“enriches” suggests that reading adds to one’s knowledge, awareness; is rewarding, beneficial; improves one
“the mind” suggests reading is influencing something greater than just the brain; it influences our consciousness: thought, perception, emotions and imagination
“deadens” suggests video games make kids less aware, less sensitive, less vigorous; they make kids think less; lifeless
“zoning out” suggests video games make kids detached from people and things around them, unresponsive, unstimulated
Question 3
We demand that teachers provide our children with reading skills; we expect the
schools to fill them with a love of books; and yet at home we let them slump in front of the consoles. We get on with our hedonistic 21st century lives while in some other room the nippers are bleeping and zapping in speechless rapture, their passive faces washed in explosions and gore. They sit for so long that their souls seem to have been sucked down the cathode ray tube.
Show how the writer’s word choice in lines 11–16 reinforces the contrast he is
creating between school and home. 2 marks
Q3-Answer
For full marks both school and home must be dealt with in order to explore the contrast. Marks will depend on the quality of comment.
Possible answers:
School:
“demand” suggests sense of authoritative claim
“provide” suggests nurturing, caring
“expect” suggests responsibility for child’s learning lies with the school
“fill” suggests idea of achieving capacity
“love (of books)” suggests intensity of emotion, goes beyond the merely functional
Q3-Answer…continued
Home:
“slump” suggests unthinking passivity, slovenly posture and attitude
“hedonistic” suggests selfish pursuit of (parents‟) own pleasures
“some other (room)” vagueness suggests lack of concern, couldn’t-care-less attitude
“nippers” suggests a rather demeaning, patronising, offhand attitude
“bleeping and zapping” suggests pointless, repetitive, noisy, slightly aggressive
“speechless rapture” suggests hypnotic state where words are superfluous
“passive” suggests no active responsibility taken for their learning/ no real engagement on the children’s part
“washed” suggests completely covered, submerged, not under control
“explosions and gore” suggests excess of mindless violence
“so long” suggests prolonged inactivity which seems to lead to their being absorbed by the machine
“sucked” suggests surrender of their very being
Figures of Speech
This is About…
Worked Example
And all of these worlds overlap in space and time. London is different for all its people. They make the most of the elements in it that have meaning for them and ignore the rest. A city is an à la carte menu. That is what makes it different from a village, which has little room for tolerance and difference. And a great city is one in which as many people as possible can make the widest of choices from its menu.
Show how the image of the “à la carte menu” illustrates the point the writer is making in these lines. 2 marks
Worked Example
And all of these worlds overlap in space and time. London is different for all its people. They make the most of the elements in it that have meaning for them and ignore the rest. A city is an à la carte menu. That is what makes it different from a village, which has little room for tolerance and difference. And a great city is one in which as many people as possible can make the widest of choices from its menu.
Think about what is being compared: i. A city and ii. An à la carte menu (i.e. a menu where you have lots of choices and can choose the items you want.)
What are the similarities between these two things? Look for clues in the surrounding passage.
Structure your answer in the following way: Just as an à la carte menu is…so too is a city…
Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment on the image. An insightful comment could score up to 2 marks; a more basic comment will be worth up to 1 mark.
Answers must show recognition of the literal root of the image and then explore how the writer is extending it figuratively.
Possible answer:
JUST AS an “à la carte menu” allows diners to make an individual choice from a varied, extensive list of dishes; SO TOO, the writer is suggesting that people in London are able to make a series of individual lifestyle choices from a very wide variety of activities, jobs, cultures, pursuits.
NB A candidate who focuses exclusively on ideas of sophistication, class or quality implied by the image may also score up to 2 marks.
Over to You!
You are now going to use what you have been learning to answer a range of different figure of speech questions.
Each question is followed by the SQA answer and you should compare this with what you have written.
Question 4
The most powerful example of this trend is found in the world of video games. And the first and last thing that should be said about the experience of playing today’s video games, the thing you almost never hear, is that games are fiendishly, sometimes maddeningly, hard. The dirty little secret of gaming is how much time you spend not having fun. You may be frustrated; you may be confused or disorientated; you may be stuck. But when you put the game down and move back into the real world, you may find yourself mentally working through the problem you have been wrestling with, as though you were worrying a loose tooth.
Show how, in these lines, the writer conveys the difficulty of playing video games by his use of imagery. 2 marks
Question 4-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment will be worth 2 marks; more basic comments will be worth up to 1 mark each.
Mere identification of an image: 0.
When dealing with imagery, answers must show recognition of the literal root of the image and then explore how the writer is extending it figuratively.
Possible answers:
“stuck” – just as to be stuck is to be fixed immovably; so too it suggests being trapped in a situation which offers no escape
“wrestling” – just as wrestling involves close, physical combat with a single opponent; so too it suggests a demanding, exhausting battle with an unforgiving enemy
“worrying a loose tooth” – just as this involves the constant working away at a persistent physical annoyance; so too it suggests that the difficulties presented by video games are nagging frustrations that constantly prey on one’s mind
NB Comment could possibly be made on “dirty little secret”, but it will be hard to relate this convincingly to “the difficulties of playing video games”. It could be argued that the expression is usually used in the realms of ethics or morality, a deliberate attempt to hide the truth, a cover-up of some sort, a hidden scandal; used in relation to the difficulty of video games, it heightens the potentially damaging nature of this feature, suggests it is a very negative feature that is deliberately glossed over.
Question 5
Well, that’s just it. Turbo-consumerism—the age of instant gratification and voracious appetite for “stuff”—cannot make us happy and it never will. Every time we are seduced into buying one product, another appears that is “new”, “improved”, better than the one you have. Turbo-consumerism is the heroin of human happiness, reliant on the fact that our needs are never satisfied. A consumer society can’t allow us to stop shopping and be content because then the whole system would die. Instead it has to sell us just enough to keep us going but never enough that our wants are satisfied. The brief high we feel is compensation for not having a richer, fuller life.
Show how the writer uses imagery in lines 18–25 to emphasise her criticism of consumerism. 2 marks
Question 5-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. An insightful comment could score up to 2 marks; a weaker comment will be worth up to 1 mark.
Mere identification of an image: 0.
When dealing with imagery, answers must show recognition of the literal root of the image and then explore how the writer is extending it figuratively.
Possible answers/comments:
“Turbo-(consumerism)” just as a turbo is a supercharger which gives an engine or mechanical system much more power, so the writer suggests that consumerism has become overpowering, having the potential to overwhelm other more meaningful aspects of life
“voracious appetite” just as a voracious appetite describes an insatiable desire to consume food greedily/ravenously, so consumerism encourages an over-indulgent approach to shopping
“seduced” to seduce is to tempt an individual, possibly into a sexual liaison or an unwise deed, so the writer suggests that the temptations of consumerism are hard to resist and may corrupt us
“heroin” just as heroin is a highly addictive narcotic, so the writer suggests that we can become dependent on consumerism
“(brief) high” just as a high is a temporary feeling of extreme happiness, so the writer suggests that consumerism offers only fleeting pleasure
Sentence Structure
This is About…
Worked Example
You see their traces in the Spitalfields district, where a French Huguenot chapel became, successively, a synagogue and a mosque, tracking the movement of waves of migrants from poverty to suburban comfort. London’s a place without an apparent structure that has proved extraordinarily successful at growing and changing. Its old residential core, sheltering in the approaches to its Tower of London fortress, has made the transition into the world’s busiest banking centre. Its market halls and power stations have become art galleries and piazzas. Its simple terraced streets, built for the clerks of the Great Western Railway in Southall, have become home to the largest Sikh community outside India.
Show how the sentence structure of the paragraph as a whole emphasises the idea of change. 2 marks
Worked Example
You see their traces in the Spitalfields district, where a French Huguenot chapel became, successively, a synagogue and a mosque, tracking the movement of waves of migrants from poverty to suburban comfort. London’s a place without an apparent structure that has proved extraordinarily successful at growing and changing. Its old residential core, sheltering in the approaches to its Tower of London fortress, has made the transition into the world’s busiest banking centre. Its market halls and power stations have become art galleries and piazzas. Its simple terraced streets, built for the clerks of the Great Western Railway in Southall, have become home to the largest Sikh community outside India.
When thinking about structure, aim to spot any relevant features which you know e.g.
Repetition of openings of sentences
Repetition of a particular formula e.g. in this case there are a number of sentences explaining what something was like before compared to what it is like after
Repetition of a verb pattern
Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment will be worth 2 marks; more basic comments will be worth up to 1 mark each. Mere identification of a feature of sentence structure: 0.
For full marks, candidates should focus on:
parallel openings (“Its old residential core”, “Its market halls and power stations”, “Its simple terraced streets”)
repeated “before and after” formula
similar verb pattern “has made the transition”, “have become” (twice)
any/all of these features are used to stress the repetitive nature, widespread scale and perhaps the inevitability of change
Comments on other features of sentence structure could be rewarded if there is some attempt to link them to the paragraph “as a whole”.
Over to You!
You are now going to use what you have been learning to answer a range of different sentence structure questions.
Each question is followed by the SQA answer and you should compare this with what you have written.
Question 6
There are several problems with this. One is that this is a city with historic and deep inequalities, a city of sharp divisions in income, employment, life chances and health. Another is that it can be seen as promoting a way of living that is unsustainable in terms of people’s disposable income and growing levels of debt. And yet another problem is the clutter of cities on the world-class trail with the same familiar formula supporting their campaign—shopping, tourism, mega-events, cultural events, iconic architecture and casinos—leaving little room for distinctiveness.
Explain fully how the structure of these lines helps to clarify the writer’s argument. 2 marks
Question 6-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment will be worth up to 2 marks; a more basic point will be worth 1 mark. Mere identification of a feature: 0.
Possible points and comments:
simple declarative sentence “There are several …” sets up clearly and plainly the expectation of a number of examples of the problems in the remainder of the paragraph
“One … Another … And yet another” to signal each of the three problems separately allowing each to be readily identified
cumulative effect of “One …Another … And yet another” culminates in the “problem” which has been the subject of the article up to this point in the passage
increasing length and detail devoted to each problem highlights the most important problem (so far)
parenthesis/list (lines 25-26) allows writer to demonstrate/mock the type of tedious, predictable, formulaic campaign of which he is so dismissive
Question 7
Never mind that the universal presence of adequate heating has almost eliminated those perennial scourges of the poor—bronchitis and pneumonia—which once took the very young and the very old in huge numbers every winter. Never mind that the generous use of hot water and detergent, particularly when combined in a washing machine for the laundering of bed linen and clothing, has virtually eliminated the infestations of body lice and fleas (which once carried plague) that used to be a commonplace feature of poverty. Never mind that the private car, the Green Public Enemy Number One, has given ordinary families freedom and flexibility that would have been inconceivable in previous generations.
Show how the writer uses sentence structure in these lines to strengthen her argument. 2 marks
Question 7-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment will be worth 2 marks; more basic comments will be worth up to 1 mark each. Mere identification of a feature of sentence structure: 0.
Possible answers:
repetition of “Never mind …” stresses her vehement, outraged opposition to so many of the restrictive measures (described previously) and/or
the cumulative effect of having three sentences all starting with “Never mind” shows that she is opposed to the eco-lobby for a variety of reasons/on a variety of fronts
repetition in “the very young and the very old” stresses that it is the most vulnerable members of society who would be put most at risk by such restrictions
parenthesis (dashes) allows her to name two particularly frightening/dangerous diseases, thus underlining the vital importance of heating/extreme dangers in cutting down on heating
Parenthesis (brackets) allows her to show the horrific threat posed by these pests, “plague” being associated with widespread, uncontrollable death
Parenthesis (commas) the insertion of “Green Public Enemy Number One” allows the writer to slip in a satirical jab at (what she perceives as) the silly, over-the-top scaremongering of the eco-lobby
Question 8
The most powerful example of this trend is found in the world of video games. And the first and last thing that should be said about the experience of playing today’s video games, the thing you almost never hear, is that games are fiendishly, sometimes maddeningly, hard. The dirty little secret of gaming is how much time you spend not having fun. You may be frustrated; you may be confused or disorientated; you may be stuck. But when you put the game down and move back into the real world, you may find yourself mentally working through the problem you have been wrestling with, as though you were worrying a loose tooth.
Show how, in these lines, the writer conveys the difficulty of playing video games by his use of sentence structure. 2 marks
Question 8-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment will be worth 2 marks; more basic comments will be worth up to 1 mark each. Mere identification of a feature of sentence structure: 0.
Possible answers:
positioning of (or rhythmic/repetitive nature of) “And the first and last thing”; definitive “alpha and omega” nature of this phrase, especially when placed at the start of the sentence, suggests the difficulty of video games is a fundamental point to the writer
use of parenthesis “the thing …hear” adds to the mystery, adds to the dramatic build-up to the final announcement of video games‟ difficulty
additional phrase “sometimes maddeningly”; two functions: again adds to the build-up and/or ramps up the notion of extreme difficulty that “fiendishly” has introduced
Candidates may attempt a more general point, incorporating aspects of points 1–3, about the various ways in which the writer builds up to/delays the climax of the (ultimately slightly lame) “hard” continued…
Q8-Answer - continued
use of climax in the sentence “The dirty …fun.” somewhat awkward/unusual construction of this sentence is designed to stress the “not having fun” element of its conclusion
repetition of the “you may be” structure stresses – and this is heightened by the use of the inclusive direct address – the variety of problems playing video games may cause
list of adjectives (“frustrated”, “confused”, “disorientated”, “stuck”) rat-a-tat run of adjectives suggests „the sea of troubles‟ playing video games may involve
anticlimax(?) of “you may be stuck” in its definitive downbeat simplicity, it is a stark summation of the seemingly insoluble challenge these games present
use of the continuous tense in final sentence an argument might be made that this reflects the ongoing, nagging nature of the problems involved
Tone
This is About…
Some Examples of Tone
Worked Example
The only solution—and I am just waiting for the politicians to recommend it explicitly—is for none of us to go anywhere. Stay at home and save the planet. But that would be a craven retreat from all the social, professional and cultural interactions that unrestricted mobility makes possible—and which, since the Renaissance, have made great cities the centres of intellectual progress.
In the paragraph, the writer states that “The only solution…is for none of us to go anywhere.”
Show how, in this paragraph, the writer creates a tone which conveys her disapproval of the “solution”. 2 marks
Worked Example
The only solution—and I am just waiting for the politicians to recommend it explicitly—is for none of us to go anywhere. Stay at home and save the planet. But that would be a craven retreat from all the social, professional and cultural interactions that unrestricted mobility makes possible—and which, since the Renaissance, have made great cities the centres of intellectual progress.
This type of question requires you to look at the words which the writer has chosen and think about how these show her disapproval.
With tone questions it can be useful to imagine the writer saying these words aloud.
Answer
Identification of tone alone: 0. Some candidates may identify a negative tone (angry, scathing, dismissive, sarcastic, caustic …) or they may just assume the tone is one of “disapproval”. Some candidates, however, may focus on the more positive, celebratory tone adopted by the writer in the second half of the paragraph which also conveys her disapproval of the anti-mobility “solution”.
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment on one of the following will be worth 2 marks; more basic comments will be worth up to 1 mark each. Reference alone: 0.
Possible answers:
“and I am just waiting” suggests writer’s world-weary mistrust of politicians and the inevitability of their actions
“none/anywhere” emphasising the extreme nature of the “solution”
“craven retreat” suggests the “solution” would be a cowardly, unworthy, retrograde step
“Renaissance” positive reference to a very enlightened, progressive, civilised period continued…
Answer - continued
“intellectual progress” suggests society/civilisation moving forward in very considered, enlightened manner
parenthesis (“and I am… explicitly”) knowing aside to the readers about the bandwagon-joining propensities of politicians
“Stay at home and save the planet.” This parody of facile, instant sloganeering shows the writer’s contempt for the quick-fix solutions of the eco-lobby
“social, professional and cultural” accumulated list of benefits made possible by mobility
structure of the final sentence; the positioning (and the bluntness) of “But that” presages her explicit rejection of the “solution” and/or the dash (followed by “and”) is used to introduce an additional point to the argument, effectively building the sentence to a resonant, powerful, pro-mobility climax
Over to You!
You are now going to use what you have been learning to answer a range of different tone questions.
Each question is followed by the SQA answer and you should compare this with what you have written.
Question 9
The politicians and the Establishment talk the language of “opportunity”, “choice” and “diversity” for the people of the city, but do not really believe in or practise them. They impose a set menu, rather than the choice offered “à la carte”, confident that they know best. For all the rhetoric about new ways of working, partnership and collaboration, there can still be a very old-fashioned top-down approach in parts of institutional Glasgow that retains a faith that experts and professionals must hold all the answers. There is an implicit belief that people are poor because of low aspirations and Glaswegians are unhealthy because they won’t accept responsibility, make the right choices and eat healthily.
Show how the writer’s use of language in this paragraph creates a tone of disapproval. 2 marks
Question 9-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment will be worth 2 marks; more basic comments will be worth up to 1 mark each. Mere identification of a feature of sentence structure: 0.
For full marks, candidates should focus on:
parallel openings (“Its old residential core”, “Its market halls and power stations”, “Its simple terraced streets”)
repeated “before and after” formula
similar verb pattern “has made the transition”, “have become” (twice)
any/all of these features are used to stress the repetitive nature, widespread scale and perhaps the inevitability of change
Comments on other features of sentence structure could be rewarded if there is some attempt to link them to the paragraph “as a whole”.
Question 10
A remedy such as carbon-neutralising our flights is a nice, cuddly idea that on the surface is a positive action to take, but planting trees in Thailand or handing out eco-lightbulbs in Honduras is no substitute for getting planes out of the skies. It also carries the risk that people will think “job done” and simply carry on flying regardless.
Show how the writer, in these lines, creates a dismissive tone when discussing possible remedies. 2 marks
Question 10-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of explanation. A single point well explained and supported by suitable reference could score up to 2 marks. A more basic comment will score 1 mark. Reference alone or mere identification of feature: 0.
Possible answers:
“nice cuddly idea” suggests something childish, spuriously comforting and/or use of colloquial language is incongruous when juxtaposed with scientific terminology beforehand
“on the surface” suggests superficial thinking
references to Thailand and Honduras selection of worthy activities/distant locations to convey relatively low-impact options
“handing out” suggests a mere distribution exercise, an easy option, something rather patronising
“job done” flippancy of short-term fix idea
“(simply) carry on flying” clichéd, complacent attitude of those indifferent to looking for remedies
“regardless” the last word in passage highlights irresponsibility
Other Types of Questions
Other types of analysis questions which you should be aware of are dealt with on the following slides. These are Linking Questions and Context Questions.
In recent years there have been no questions of this type in the final exam but it is still useful to know how to answer them in case any appear in future papers.
Linking Questions
This is About…
Context Questions
This is About…
Evaluation Questions
This is About…
Worked Example
Warnings of catastrophe come and go. Whatever their validity, we cannot and should not ask people to go back to a more restricted way of life. The restrictions would not work anyway, because they are impracticable. If they were enforced, they would be grotesquely unfair and socially divisive. If we really are facing an environmental crisis, then we are going to have to innovate and engineer our way out of it.
How effective do you find the writer’s use of language in this final paragraph in emphasising her opposition to placing restrictions on people’s way of life?
2 marks
Worked Example
Warnings of catastrophe come and go. Whatever their validity, we cannot and should not ask people to go back to a more restricted way of life. The restrictions would not work anyway, because they are impracticable. If they were enforced, they would be grotesquely unfair and socially divisive. If we really are facing an environmental crisis, then we are going to have to innovate and engineer our way out of it.
You should look for examples of “language” which means word choice, imagery, sentence structure, tone.
You should then comment on how these allow us to see that the writer is opposed to any restrictions being placed on people’s lives.
Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. A single insightful comment could score up to 2 marks; more basic points will be worth up to 1 mark.
The following points could be made, but all points which candidates propose will have to be judged on their merits.
“Warnings of catastrophe come and go” suggests such warnings are transient, unimportant, not unusual; not worthy of the current over-reaction (a case might be made that the shortness of this sentence suggests a blunt, unequivocal dismissal on the writer’s part)
“Whatever their validity” suggests writer’s scepticism
“we cannot and should not”. Rhetorical repetition and cadence to emphasise, assertive, decisive opposition
“more restricted way of life” suggests loss of freedom
“anyway” dismissive tone, rejecting underlying concept of restrictions
Answer…continued…
“impracticable” highlights fundamental flaws in the proposals
“grotesquely unfair” suggests a monstrous, outlandish travesty of justice
“socially divisive” suggests an attack on the very fabric of society
repetition of the “If” structure in the final two sentences could be argued that this brings the passage to a climax: the penultimate sentence an emphatic summing-up of her objections, the final sentence an affirmation of her belief in human resourcefulness
repetition of “we” throughout paragraph suggests writer is taking a stand for all of us; underlines her belief that this is something we can solve together as opposed to being dictated to by government
general use of pairs as a rhetorical device: “cannot and should not”, “grotesquely unfair and socially divisive”, “innovate and engineer”; candidates may find the repetitive use of this device gives the paragraph a persuasive certainty. On the other hand, they may find it somewhat repetitive, wearisome, contrived, mechanical, . . .
Over to You!
You are now going to use what you have been learning to answer a range of different evaluation questions.
Each question is followed by the SQA answer and you should compare this with what you have written.
Question 11
But even in this self-interested arena a representative from the US Federal Aviation Administration caused some sharp intakes of breath from the audience by showing an extraordinary map of current flight paths etched over one another on the world’s surface. The only places on Earth that are not scarred by routes are blocks of air space over the central Pacific, the southern Atlantic and Antarctica.
How effective do you find the writer’s use of imagery in these lines in conveying the impact that flying has on the environment? 2 marks
Question 11-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of evaluative comment. For full marks there must be attention to the idea of “conclusion” and to the “condemnation … in the passage as a whole”.
The following points could be made, but all points which candidates propose will have to be judged on their merits.
“So I say now:” Churchillian call to arms which signals the start of the peroration
“sitting in auto-lobotomy” recalls description used in paragraph 3 (lines 11-16), and this reminds us of the detrimental effects of video gaming on young people
use of imperatives - “Summon”, “Steel”, “yank out”, “get out”, “strike” takes the reader back to the turning off of the equipment at the beginning of the passage because the writer feels action must be taken
“all your strength, all your courage” rhetorical patterning to reinforce the effort required by adults to overcome their offspring’s addiction
Question 12
So I say now: go to where your children are sitting in auto-lobotomy in front of the console. Summon up all your strength, all your courage. Steel yourself for the screams and yank out that plug. And if they still kick up a fuss, then get out the sledgehammer and strike a blow for literacy.
How effective do you find these lines as a conclusion to the writer’s condemnation of video gaming in the passage as a whole? 3 marks
Question 12-Answer
“sledgehammer” cartoon-like exaggeration typical of whole passage
final five words “strike a blow for literacy” brings together writer’s literal and metaphorical use of the expression in the title and at the end to illustrate the value he attaches to literacy
tone remains consistent faux-outrage throughout, building to this ludicrous ending
argues that the situation is so serious that parents need to take decisive action to remedy the problem
returns to the initial scenario to remind the reader of the “logical” need to take action
Question 13
Am I over-catastrophising the consumer phenomenon? In the Liverpool One shopping “experience”, where I am sitting, a place teeming with shoppers despite the credit crunch, and punctuated by Massive Reductions! signs, people don’t look particularly disempowered or depressed. Purposeful, I suppose, but also strangely distracted, as if they do not notice the environment around them, merely the magnetic shop signs. I understand the siren call of TK Maxx and how a £3 top can mend a bad day. But the question is, why does it?
To what extent does her description of the shoppers in these lines suggest that the writer believes she is “over-catastrophising the consumer phenomenon”? 2 marks
Question 13-Answer
Candidates could argue either way or on both sides. A basic point will be worth 1 mark; a more developed answer will be worth 2 marks. Reference alone: 0.
Possible answers:
1. “teeming with shoppers despite the credit crunch” suggests it’s not a problem, because so many are still shopping and benefiting the economy (even in financially strained times)
2. “people don’t look … disempowered” suggests it’s not a problem, because these shoppers still have the right to make their own decisions
3. “people don’t look … depressed” suggests it’s not a problem, because the shoppers do not appear to be unhappy
4. “purposeful” suggests it’s not a problem, because the shoppers are clear- sighted in their aims
Q13-Answer…continued
“teeming with shoppers despite the credit crunch” suggests it is a problem, because large numbers are shopping even though they can ill afford to
use of qualifying adverb “particularly” before “disempowered or depressed” suggests that the writer cannot be whole-heartedly positive in her description of the shoppers
“I suppose” suggests a reluctance on the writer’s part to see consumers in a positive light
“strangely distracted … magnetic shop signs” suggests it is a problem, because the shoppers are not in control of their own actions, are in an almost hypnotic state
Question 14
Back at the mall, I speak to two young shoppers staggering under the weight of their carrier bags. Will they go home now and put their feet up? “No, we’re taking these bags home in a taxi,” says one. “Then we’re coming back to do another hour before the shops close.”
To what extent do you find the reference to the “two young shoppers” in these lines an effective way to conclude the ideas of the passage? 2 marks
Question 14-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. For full marks there must be attention to the idea of a conclusion. The following points could be made, but all points which candidates propose will have to be judged on their merits.
the attitude and behaviour of the “two young shoppers” are the embodiment of “modern consumerism” as mentioned in the opening sentence; they follow the creed of “live to shop”, illustrating the idea behind the title
the “two young shoppers”, as a device, allow the writer to return to the physical setting of the mall which is used at the beginning, in the middle and at the end, illustrating the scale of the shopping phenomenon
the “two young shoppers” provide a circular structure to the passage because the writer introduces “a young woman” near the beginning who is also laden with her purchases and engaged “in turbo-consumerism”
Question 14-Answer
Marks will depend on the quality of comment. For full marks there must be attention to the idea of a conclusion.
The following points could be made, but all points which candidates propose will have to be judged on their merits.
the attitude and behaviour of the “two young shoppers” are the embodiment of “modern consumerism” as mentioned in the opening sentence; they follow the creed of “live to shop”, illustrating the idea behind the title
the “two young shoppers”, as a device, allow the writer to return to the physical setting of the mall which is used at the beginning, in the middle and at the end, illustrating the scale of the shopping phenomenon
the “two young shoppers” provide a circular structure to the passage because the writer introduces “a young woman” near the beginning who is also laden with her purchases and engaged “in turbo-consumerism”
Expert Gallery Tour Revision
Your group will now be assigned one of the types of question which you have been looking at in this unit.
You will spend some time in your groups consolidating everything you know about answering that type of question, including any of your own tips which you may have picked up along the way. You can look back at your Learning Log for help.
You are now an ‘Expert Group’ on this type of question! You will shortly be visited by members of the other groups on their Gallery Tour.
Your job is to explain what you know about your type of question and to answer any queries which your visitors may have:
Word Choice
Linking Questions; Context Questions
Figures of Speech
Sentence structure
Tone
Evaluation Questions
How it Works
A minimum of 2 members of your group will wait at the Expert Gallery and explain to visitors what your type of question is all about.
Two or more of the rest of your group will visit each of the expert galleries to hear what they have to say about their type of question.
When this stage of the task is complete, the visitors will now become the Expert Galleries and the original experts will become the visitors.
The purpose of this task is to ensure that everyone has a full understanding of Analysis and Evaluation questions. Therefore, you should make a note of anything new which you learn in this task.
Re-Cap
So what have you learned about Analysis and Evaluation questions?
What should you remember when answering each type of these questions in the exam?
Spend the next 5 minutes writing down as many things as you can that you have learned in this unit.
Challenge: Can you be the person at your group who has remembered something which no one else has?!