A Q A C O M B I N E D S C I E N C E · B I O L O G Y
Osmosis
Topic 1 Cell biology · Lesson 7
A Q A C O M B I N E D S C I E N C E · B I O L O G Y
Osmosis
Topic 1 Cell biology · Lesson 7
Biology Lesson 7 of the GCSE Combined Science series. Written for AQA Combined Science Trilogy 8464, section 4.1.3.2 (Osmosis), including Required Practical 2 (the effect of a range of concentrations of salt or sugar solutions on the mass of plant tissue), Biology Paper 1.
Structure: 01 Hook, 02 Learn, 03 Check (including the Professor), 04 Go Higher (pink HIGHER badge), 05 Apply and Review. Foundation groups can stop before section 04.
The practical itself takes a lesson plus an overnight wait; this lesson teaches the method and the maths, and works with sample results.
0 1 / H O O K
A floppy lettuce leaf is left in a bowl of cold water for an hour. What happens?
It goes crisp again
It goes even floppier
Nothing changes
It dissolves
B I O L O G Y
Take a vote and use the spinner to hear a few reasons.
It goes crisp again. Water moves into the leaf cells, they swell and press against their cell walls, and the leaf firms up. Chefs use this trick. The next slide names it.
0 1 / H O O K
Crisp again - by osmosis!
Water moved into the lettuce cells, so they swelled and went firm.
This kind of diffusion - of water, through a membrane - is called osmosis.
Today: what osmosis is, which way the water goes, and a required practical with potatoes.
B I O L O G Y
Osmosis is a special case of diffusion. Biology 6 covered diffusion; Biology 8 covers active transport.
T O D A Y ' S G O A L S
By the end of the lesson
Foundation
I can define osmosis.
I can predict whether water moves into or out of a cell.
I can describe Required Practical 2 and calculate percentage change in mass.
Higher
I can use a graph of results to find the concentration inside plant cells.
I can calculate a percentage loss in mass.
B I O L O G Y
Share the goals. Foundation goals are for everyone; the Higher goals are covered in section 04.
0 2 / L E A R N
What is osmosis?
Osmosis is the diffusion of water from a dilute solution to a more concentrated solution, through a partially permeable membrane.
The membrane lets small water molecules through, but not bigger ones like sugar.
B I O L O G Y
AQA 4.1.3.2: "Water may move across cell membranes via osmosis. Osmosis is the diffusion of water from a dilute solution to a concentrated solution through a partially permeable membrane."
A dilute solution has a lot of water and little dissolved substance. So water still moves from where there is more water to where there is less - just like diffusion.
0 3 / C H E C K
Osmosis is the movement of which substance through a membrane?
Sugar
Oxygen
Water
Salt
Answer: water. Sugar and salt are dissolved in the water but cannot cross a partially permeable membrane; oxygen moves by diffusion.
0 2 / L E A R N
Which way does the water go?
Compare the solution outside the cell with the cytoplasm inside.
More dilute outside (e.g. pure water): water moves in. The cell swells and gains mass.
More concentrated outside (e.g. strong sugar): water moves out. The cell shrinks and loses mass.
The same: no net movement.
Plant cells have a cell wall, so they go firm instead of bursting.
B I O L O G Y
Animal cells have no cell wall, so in pure water they can swell and burst; in a strong solution they shrivel. Plant cells in pure water go firm (turgid); in a strong solution they go floppy.
The words turgid and plasmolysed are not required by AQA Combined Science, but are useful for discussion.
0 3 / C H E C K
A potato cell is put in pure water. What happens?
Water moves in
Water moves out
Sugar moves in
Nothing happens
Answer: water moves in by osmosis - the pure water is more dilute than the cytoplasm. The cell gains mass and goes firm. Image credit: Lars Blankers / Unsplash
Drag each statement to the right box
WATER MOVES INTO THE CELL
WATER MOVES OUT OF THE CELL
The cell loses mass
The cell is in pure water
The cell is in strong sugar solution
A plant cell goes firm
The cell shrinks
The cell gains mass
B I O L O G Y
Water moves in: the cell is in pure water; a plant cell goes firm; the cell gains mass. Water moves out: the cell loses mass; the cell is in strong sugar solution; the cell shrinks.
0 2 / L E A R N
Required Practical 2
1 Cut potato cylinders the same size.
2 Blot dry and weigh each one.
3 Put one in each sugar solution, and leave overnight.
4 Remove, blot dry to take off surface water, and reweigh.
5 Calculate the % change in mass.
B I O L O G Y
AQA Required Practical 2: "Use a range of concentrations of salt or sugar solutions to investigate the effect on the mass of plant tissue."
Independent variable: concentration of the solution. Dependent variable: % change in mass. Control variables: size and type of potato cylinder, volume of solution, time left, temperature. Blotting removes surface water, which would add mass that never went into the cells.
0 2 / L E A R N
Working out % change
The cylinders start at slightly different masses, so we compare the percentage change, not the change in grams.
% change = (final mass − starting mass) ÷ starting mass × 100
Worked example: 2.5 g → 2.8 g
2.8 − 2.5 = 0.3 g → 0.3 ÷ 2.5 = 0.12 → × 100 = +12%
A gain is positive (water moved in). A loss is negative (water moved out).
B I O L O G Y
Always divide by the STARTING mass. A common mistake is dividing by the final mass.
0 3 / C H E C K
Why is each potato cylinder blotted dry before it is weighed?
To add more sugar
To remove surface water
To kill the cells
To stop osmosis
Answer: to remove water on the outside of the cylinder. That water never entered the cells, so it would make the mass reading too high. Blotting the same way each time keeps it a fair test.
0 3 / C H E C K
A cylinder goes from 2.0 g to 2.3 g. What is the percentage change?
+0.3%
+13%
+15%
+30%
Answer: +15%. 2.3 − 2.0 = 0.3 g; 0.3 ÷ 2.0 = 0.15; × 100 = 15%. +13% divides by the final mass (0.3 ÷ 2.3); +0.3% forgets to divide. Image credit: User_Pascal / Unsplash
T H E A N S W E R S E X P L A I N E D
How did we get those?
Osmosis: it is always water that moves. Sugar is too big to cross the membrane.
Pure water: more dilute than the cell, so water moves in.
Blotting: removes surface water that never went into the cells.
% change: 2.3 − 2.0 = 0.3 g. 0.3 ÷ 2.0 × 100 = +15%. Divide by the starting mass.
B I O L O G Y
Go through all four after the votes. Anyone who chose +13% divided by the final mass.
0 3 / C H E C K
"Put a potato chip in strong sugar solution and it gets HEAVIER - the sugar soaks in!" Is the Professor right? Explain.
T H E P R O F E S S O R S A Y S . . .
B I O L O G Y
The Professor's misconception, as an open question - students type their answers. This time he has his skeleton with him.
He is wrong. The strong sugar solution is more concentrated than the cytoplasm, so water moves OUT of the potato cells by osmosis. The sugar molecules are too big to pass through the partially permeable membrane. The chip gets lighter and floppier.
Look for: "water moves out", "osmosis", "more concentrated outside", "sugar can't cross the membrane", "loses mass".
T H E A N S W E R E X P L A I N E D
Sorry, Professor!
Sugar molecules are too big to cross the membrane, so sugar does not soak in.
The strong solution is more concentrated than the cell, so water moves out by osmosis.
The chip loses mass and goes floppy - it gets lighter, not heavier.
B I O L O G Y
Go through this after students have typed their answers. The results graph in the Higher section shows exactly this - big losses in strong solutions.
Osmosis recap
Osmosis is the diffusion of water from a dilute solution to a more concentrated solution through a partially permeable membrane. A potato cylinder in pure water gains mass. In a strong sugar solution it loses mass. We compare results using the percentage change, dividing by the starting mass.
B I O L O G Y
A recap of the Foundation section. "Sugar" tests the Professor's misconception; "final" tests the % change mistake.
S P E C C H E C K
Your exam spec
Osmosis and the potato practical are in every specification.
AQA Combined Science Trilogy (8464) - 4.1.3.2 Osmosis and Required Practical 2, Biology Paper 1.
Edexcel Combined Science (1SC0) - Topic 1: osmosis, with a core practical on osmosis in potatoes.
OCR Gateway Combined Science (J250) - Cell level systems: osmosis, with a practical activity (PAG).
CCEA Double Award Science (NI) - Biology: osmosis, with a prescribed practical.
B I O L O G Y
A variant slide for classes on other specifications. The method is much the same everywhere; check whether your board uses sugar or salt solutions and how it names the practical.
Delete this slide if your class only sits AQA.
0 4 / G O H I G H E R
Reading the results graph
Above 0: the potato gained water.
Below 0: it lost water.
Where the line crosses 0, there is no net movement - the solution has the same concentration as the inside of the potato cells.
Here: about 0.44 M.
B I O L O G Y
HIGHER
Higher slide. Students should draw a line of best fit through the points, then read off where it crosses the x-axis. Real results scatter; the crossing point is an estimate.
0 4 / G O H I G H E R
What does the point where the line crosses 0% tell you?
HIGHER
The potato cells have died
All the water has left
Same concentration as the cells
The sugar has run out
Answer: at that concentration there is no net movement of water, so the solution has the same concentration as the cytoplasm of the potato cells - about 0.44 M here.
0 4 / G O H I G H E R
A cylinder goes from 2.50 g to 2.20 g. What is the percentage change?
HIGHER
−0.3%
−12%
−13.6%
+12%
Answer: −12%. 2.20 − 2.50 = −0.30 g; −0.30 ÷ 2.50 = −0.12; × 100 = −12%. −13.6% divides by the final mass; +12% forgets that it is a loss. Image credit: jkoblitz / Unsplash
T H E A N S W E R S E X P L A I N E D
How did we get those?
Crossing point: no gain and no loss, so no net movement of water. The solution must match the concentration inside the cells.
Loss: 2.20 − 2.50 = −0.30 g. Then −0.30 ÷ 2.50 × 100 = −12%.
Keep the minus sign: it shows the potato lost water.
B I O L O G Y
HIGHER
Talk through both Higher answers. Ask what the graph would look like for a sweeter vegetable, such as a carrot or sweet potato - the crossing point moves right.
0 5 / A P P L Y & R E V I E W
Exam practice
Question
Give two variables that should be kept the same in the potato osmosis practical. [2 marks]
Working space
Model answer
Key takeaway
Only the concentration changes.
B I O L O G Y
FOUNDATION
Foundation exam question. Do not accept "the amount of potato" without saying size, length or mass; accept "same type of potato".
0 5 / A P P L Y & R E V I E W
Exam practice
Question
A potato cylinder's mass fell from 3.20 g to 2.88 g.
Calculate the percentage change and explain the result. [3 marks]
Working space
Model answer
Key takeaway
Divide by the starting mass; a loss is negative.
B I O L O G Y
HIGHER
Higher exam question. Accept "10% decrease" for the second mark. The third mark needs both osmosis (water moving out) and the reason.
These are model points in the style of an AQA mark scheme, not an official mark scheme.
0 5 / A P P L Y & R E V I E W
Exit ticket: what is osmosis, and what happens to a plant cell in a strong sugar solution?
B I O L O G Y
Exit ticket. Good answers: osmosis is the diffusion of water from a dilute to a more concentrated solution through a partially permeable membrane. In strong sugar solution water moves out of the plant cell, so it loses mass and goes floppy.
Great work, scientists!
Next biology lesson - Biology 8, Active transport.