Should Lying in Politics Be a Crime?

Should Lying in Politics Be a Crime?

Marcus Ball, the Hillsborough Law and the MPs it leaves out

1 / 14
volgende
Slide 1: Slide
newEditorNewsNews focusLower Secondary (Key Stage 3)Upper Secondary (Key Stage 4)Further Education (Key Stage 5)BTEC, GCSE

In deze les zitten 14 slides, met interactieve quizzen en tekstslides.

time-iconLesduur is: 20 min
Dit is niet oké

Introductie

A new law would make it a crime for ministers and officials to mislead the public, but backbench MPs and peers are left out. Students explore campaigner Marcus Ball's fight to change that, compare Wales's ban on election lies, and decide whether lying in politics should be a crime. Interactive activities include a drag-and-drop sort, polls and open questions. Best suited to Key Stage 3 to FE citizenship, politics or current affairs lessons, taught live in class. This lesson was created with AI assistance.

Onderdelen in deze les

Should Lying in Politics Be a Crime?

Marcus Ball, the Hillsborough Law and the MPs it leaves out

The deck asks whether lying in politics should be a crime, using the Hillsborough Law's new offence of misleading the public and campaigner Marcus Ball's fight to extend it to MPs and peers. Students weigh honesty and trust against free speech and parliamentary privilege.

Keeping it balanced: the exclusion covers MPs and peers of every party, including the whole opposition front bench, so it is not one party protecting itself. Ball's best-known case was against Boris Johnson over the Brexit bus; treat that as part of his story, not as a verdict on Brexit or on Johnson.

Sources: The Guardian (14 July 2026), BBC News (14 January and 17 March 2026), House of Lords Library (20 February 2026), Hansard (Lords, 26 February 2026), and Marcus Ball's written evidence to Parliament (March 2026). On 9 November 2026 the bill was at report stage in the House of Lords. Colours: the red benches of the House of Lords and Parliament's gold portcullis. Image credit: Linda Gerbec / Unsplash

1

Yes

2

No

3

A little

Have you seen or heard this news yet?

Note: Few students will have followed a bill through the Lords, so this opening vote shows how much background to give.

Stretch: Ask whether anyone has heard of the Hillsborough disaster or the families' long campaign for the truth.

Device-free: Thumbs up, sideways or down for Yes, A little or No.

How do you feel about this news?

Deze slide heeft geen instructies

By the end of this lesson you can...

  • Understand what the Hillsborough Law's offence of misleading the public would do, and who it would leave out.

  • Evaluate whether lying in politics should be a crime, weighing honesty and trust against free speech and parliamentary privilege.

Note: The aims move from what the law does to whether it goes far enough, so students know a judgement is expected.

Stretch: Ask students to predict which argument they will find hardest to answer.

Device-free: Students copy the aims onto mini-whiteboards and tick each one off at the end.

Key Info

What?

The Hillsborough Law would make it a crime for ministers and officials to mislead the public, but not backbench MPs.

Where?

Westminster, where the law is in the House of Lords, and Wales, which has passed its own election lying ban.

Who?

Campaigner Marcus Ball, Hillsborough families, Labour MP Luke Myer, and peers debating whether Parliament should be included.

Note: The offence would cover the Prime Minister, ministers, civil servants, police, NHS staff and the armed forces. The House of Commons and House of Lords are listed as "excluded bodies".

Stretch: Ask why the families of the 97 people who died at Hillsborough in 1989 campaigned for a law about honesty.

Device-free: In pairs, students sum up What, Where and Who in a single sentence. Image credit: Jametlene Reskp / Unsplash Image credit: Wikivoyage contributor, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons Image credit: UK Parliament, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Background

Since 2016, Marcus Ball has tried to make lying in politics a crime; in 2019 he took Boris Johnson to court over the "£350m a week" Brexit bus, but the case was stopped.

The Hillsborough Law would create an offence of misleading the public, yet excludes backbench MPs and peers.

Ball says Parliament is excluding itself from its own law.

Note: The offence would never cover anything said inside Parliament, because of parliamentary privilege. The exclusion is about MPs and peers outside Parliament, and it also leaves out the whole opposition front bench (Hansard, Lords debate, 26 February 2026).

Stretch: Ball's private prosecution reached the magistrates' court before the High Court stopped it in June 2019. Ask why a court might be wary of judging a campaign slogan.

Device-free: Quick chat in pairs: is it fair that a minister could be prosecuted for misleading the public but a backbench MP could not? Image credit: Michael Fousert / Unsplash

The Big Controversy

Include MPs: Labour MP Luke Myer, backed by MPs from the Greens and Plaid Cymru, says then "no-one in parliament would be above the law".

Leave them out: others argue that parliamentary privilege, the freedom to speak without fear of being sued or prosecuted, protects democracy itself.

And: in Wales, committees warned a lying ban could limit free speech and leave courts deciding what counts as a lie.

Should MPs have to follow the same honesty law they make for everyone else?

Note: Both sides are presented as they are argued in Parliament; reveal the question with a click and give pairs a minute to pick a side.

Stretch: Students argue the side they personally disagree with, using one fact from the lesson.

Device-free: An agree–disagree line across the room in response to the question. Image credit: Hugo Sousa / Unsplash

Lie, promise, opinion or mistake?

Lie, promise, opinion or mistake?

Lie

Broken promise

Opinion

Honest mistake

A candidate says their plan is the best way to fix the NHS.

A minister says crime has fallen, knowing the figures show it has risen.

An MP quotes last year's figures without realising new ones are out.

A party promises 20,000 new teachers, then hires 12,000 after its budget is cut.

Note: These statements are made up, with no real politicians. Answers: the minister's statement is a lie, the teachers pledge is a broken promise, the NHS plan is an opinion, and last year's figures are an honest mistake.

Stretch: Marcus Ball's own draft law protects broken promises, opinions, predictions and honest mistakes, and targets only deliberate or reckless lies. Ask students whether a court could always tell the difference.

Device-free: Read each statement aloud; students hold up one to four fingers for Lie, Broken promise, Opinion or Honest mistake.

1

Yes

2

No

3

Not sure

Should the UK follow Wales and make lying in election campaigns a crime?

Note: A quick vote shows where the class stands before the reasons are explored.

Stretch: Ask students who chose "Not sure" what safeguard would win them over.

Device-free: Students stand on one side of the room for Yes, the other for No, and in the middle for Not sure.

Explain your answer from the poll

Note: Turning a vote into a written reason pushes students to evaluate rather than simply choose a side.

Stretch: Students add one counter-argument and explain why it does not change their view.

Device-free: Each student writes one sentence on a mini-whiteboard and swaps with a partner.

Who should decide whether a politician has lied: voters, Parliament or the courts?

Note: This moves the debate from whether lying is wrong to who should judge it.

Stretch: Points to look for: voters can remove MPs at elections but may not know the truth in time; Parliament can punish MPs who mislead the House, but MPs judge their own colleagues; courts are independent but could be drawn into political arguments; recall petitions and independent watchdogs are possible middle ways.

Device-free: Three columns on the board, "Voters", "Parliament" and "Courts", with one strength and one weakness for each.

Key Concepts

Parliamentary privilege — legal protection that lets MPs and peers speak freely in Parliament without being sued or prosecuted for what they say there.

Misleading the public — deliberately or recklessly giving people a false picture of something important.

Private prosecution — a criminal case brought by a member of the public rather than the Crown Prosecution Service.

Backbench MP — an MP who is not a government minister or an opposition spokesperson.

Note: These four terms give students the language to explain exactly who the law covers and why some are left out.

Stretch: Students explain, in one sentence, why parliamentary privilege exists.

Device-free: The teacher reads a definition and students call out the matching term.

What question do you have about this news?

Note: A closing open question checks what students have taken away and shows where understanding is still thin.

Stretch: Ask students where they would look for a reliable answer, such as the Parliament website or Hansard.

Device-free: Students write their question on a sticky note on the way out.

News Focus lessons - short lessons on current events

Deze slide heeft geen instructies

Meer lessen zoals deze