Testing Conjectures
Testing Conjectures
Open with the idea that in maths, noticing a pattern is only the start. The lesson is about checking whether a statement is always true, sometimes true, or never true, and using examples or algebra to justify it.
Learning goal
I can test a conjecture and decide whether it is true always, sometimes, or never.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
One word or phrase linked to testing a conjecture
Use this to surface prior ideas such as pattern, proof, example, true, false, always, sometimes, never, and counterexample.
What is a conjecture?
A conjecture is a statement we think is true because we notice a pattern.
In maths, a pattern is not enough on its own.
We test a conjecture by:
checking examples
looking for a counterexample
giving a reason or proof
Stress that one example can support a conjecture, but it cannot prove an always statement. A single counterexample is enough to disprove an always statement.
Factors, multiples and primes
These number ideas help us test conjectures.
Factor: a whole number that divides exactly
Multiple: a result of multiplying by a whole number
Prime: has exactly two factors, 1 and itself
You may remind students that 1 is not prime. Keep examples simple, such as factors of 12, multiples of 5, and primes under 20.
Always, sometimes or never?
When we test a statement, we decide which of these is correct:
Always: true for every case
Sometimes: true for some cases, but not all
Never: not true for any case
This helps us describe the truth of a conjecture clearly.
Emphasise precise language. Students often say 'true' when the better judgement is 'sometimes'.
Testing number statements
Examples:
'An even number is a multiple of 2' → always
'A prime number is odd' → sometimes
'A multiple of 5 is even' → sometimes
'A factor of 9 is greater than 9' → never
For 'prime number is odd', use 2 as the counterexample. For 'multiple of 5 is even', contrast 10 and 15.
Counterexamples matter
A counterexample is one example that shows a statement is not always true.
Example:
'All multiples of 3 are odd'
3 is odd
9 is odd
12 is even
So the statement is sometimes, not always.
Make the logic explicit: many supporting examples do not prove an always statement, but one counterexample can disprove it.
Which statement is always true?
A prime is odd
A multiple of 5 is even
An even number is a multiple of 2
A factor of 9 is greater than 9
Draw on the exact examples from the number statements slide. The key misconception is choosing a statement that is only sometimes true.
Testing number statements
A conjecture is a statement we think is true because we notice a . To test it, we can check examples, look for a , and give a reason. One counterexample shows a statement is not true. Then it may be instead.
Correct blanks, in order: pattern, counterexample, always, sometimes.
What does 'show that…' mean?
A 'show that…' question asks you to prove a statement, not just guess it.
You need to:
start with known facts
use correct steps
reach the statement logically
The answer must explain why it works.
Link this to the lesson thread: examples help us spot a pattern, but 'show that' asks for a general reason.
Showing a number result
Example: Show that the sum of two even numbers is even.
Let the even numbers be 2a and 2b.
2a + 2b = 2(a + b)
The result is 2 times a whole number, so it is even.
This may be students' first formal general argument. Explain that a and b stand for any whole numbers.
Why algebra helps
Algebra lets us test a conjecture for all cases.
Instead of checking one number at a time, we use letters to represent any number.
That is how we move from pattern to proof.
Bridge into Part 2. The key idea is generalisation: algebra captures every case, not just a few examples.
Why are examples not enough in a 'show that' question?
Expected elements: a show that question needs a logical proof or general reason, not just one or two examples. Students may mention known facts, correct steps, and explaining why it works for all cases.
What does 2a + 2b show?
Always odd
Always even
Sometimes prime
Never whole
Because 2a + 2b = 2(a + b), the sum is 2 times a whole number, so it is even.
Expanding a pair of binomials
A binomial has two terms, such as (x + 3) or (x - 5).
To expand two binomials, multiply each term in the first bracket by each term in the second.
Example:
(x + 2)(x + 5) = x² + 5x + 2x + 10 = x² + 7x + 10
Keep the structure clear: every term multiplies every term. Use area model language if helpful, but do not overload the slide.
A pattern in binomial products
Look at these examples:
(x + 1)(x + 2) = x² + 3x + 2
(x + 3)(x + 4) = x² + 7x + 12
(x + 5)(x + 6) = x² + 11x + 30
The constant term is the product of the constants.
The x-term coefficient is their sum.
Students may begin to conjecture the general rule for (x + a)(x + b). Let that idea emerge before naming it formally.
Testing a conjecture with algebra
For any numbers a and b:
(x + a)(x + b)
= x² + ax + bx + ab
= x² + (a + b)x + ab
So the conjecture is true:
x-term coefficient = a + b
constant term = ab
This is the proof of the observed pattern. Highlight that algebra shows it works for all values of a and b.
In (x + a)(x + b), the constant term is...
a + b
ab
x + a
2x
Checks the general rule after students have seen examples and the algebra proof.
Expanding two binomials
To expand two , multiply each term in the first bracket by each term in the second. For numbers a and b, (x + a)(x + b) = x² + + ab. So the x-term coefficient is the of a and b.
Correct blanks, in order: binomials, any, (a + b)x, sum.
Patterns on a 100-grid
A 100-grid helps us spot number patterns.
Moving:
right adds 1
left subtracts 1
down adds 10
up subtracts 10
Use the grid to connect arithmetic structure with conjectures. The movement rules support the next slide's pattern statements.
Conjectures from the grid
Example patterns:
Numbers in the same column have the same ones digit.
Numbers one row down are 10 more.
Two numbers next to each other differ by 1.
These patterns can be tested with examples and explained by place value.
If useful, point out that place value gives the reason: moving down changes the tens digit by 1 while the ones digit stays the same.
Generalising grid patterns
If a number on the grid is n, then:
one square right is n + 1
one square left is n - 1
one square down is n + 10
one square up is n - 10
Algebra writes the pattern in a general form.
This links the visual grid to algebraic generalisation. Students should see that the same reasoning style works in both number and algebra contexts.
On a 100-grid, one square down is...
n - 10
n + 10
n - 1
n + 1
Links the movement rule to the general form with n.
Why do numbers in one column have the same ones digit?
Expected elements: students should explain that numbers in the same column keep the same ones digit because moving up or down changes the tens by 1 ten, not the ones.
Expanding three binomials
Expand step by step.
Example:
(x + 1)(x + 2)(x + 3)
First expand two brackets:
(x + 1)(x + 2) = x² + 3x + 2
Then multiply by (x + 3).
Keep the method procedural and calm: expand two brackets first, then multiply the result by the third bracket.
Expanding three binomials
Continue the example:
(x² + 3x + 2)(x + 3)
= x³ + 3x² + 3x² + 9x + 2x + 6
= x³ + 6x² + 11x + 6
Collect like terms at the end.
Students may lose terms here, so stress systematic multiplication and checking that all parts have been included.
What the lesson shows
Testing conjectures means more than spotting a pattern.
In this lesson, patterns came from:
factors, multiples and primes
number grids
expanding binomials
Examples help us notice a rule; algebra helps us prove it.
Use this as the landing point for the central question: how do we know a conjecture is really true?
What should you do first with three binomials?
Collect like terms
Expand two brackets
Add all constants
Cube the first term
Checks the step-by-step method from the final worked example.
Expanding three binomials
To expand three binomials, work by step. First, expand two brackets. Then the result by the third bracket. At the end, collect terms to get the final .
Correct blanks, in order: step, multiply, like, expression.
What is one idea from this lesson you will remember?
Reflection prompt with no right answer. Invite students to mention number statements, counterexamples, algebra, grid patterns, or expanding brackets.
Which part of testing conjectures felt hardest today?
Reflection prompt with no right answer. Useful for planning reteaching or guided practice.
Glossary
conjecture - a statement that seems true from a pattern but still needs testing
factor - a whole number that divides another number exactly
multiple - a number found by multiplying by a whole number
prime number - a number with exactly two factors, 1 and itself
counterexample - an example that shows a statement is not always true
binomial - an expression with two terms
expand - to multiply out brackets
Deze slide heeft geen instructies