V3 - How to create a discussion statement
Lesson goal: I know how to create a discussion statement
V3 - How to create a discussion statement
Lesson goal: I know how to create a discussion statement
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
In this lesson
What's important about discussion statements?
Practice with statements
Get together and think of your own discussion statement for testweek
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
This statement is a good discussion statement!
Yes
No!
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
What's wrong with the statement: "This is a good discussion statement"
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
What do you think is needed for a discussion statement?
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Ingredients for a good discussion statement
The statement is open-ended
The statement should not be answered with a hard yes/no. It should invite people to share their opinion.
It invites multiple perspectives/views to participate in conversation.
The statement should be open to interpetation. You need to feel safe to share your thoughts and beliefs
The statement is relevant
It should have a connection with the present, or at least be possible in your current situation
You can follow up on the statement.
It should make you wonder how or why you are against/in favor of the statement. To make room for explanation
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
What's wrong with the statement: "Racism should be forbidden"
It's not open ended
It does not invite multiple perspectives
It's not relevant
You can't follow up on the statement
Racism is already forbidden by law and therefor not relevant.
It's also morraly wrong
It doesn't invite, but exludes multiple perspectives
Follow up on this statement could be hurtful
We can argue it's not open ended.
What's wrong with the statement: I like books
It's not open ended
It does not invite multiple perspectives
It's not relevant
You can't follow up on the statement
Racism is already forbidden by law and therefor not relevant.
It's also morraly wrong
It doesn't invite, but exludes multiple perspectives
Follow up on this statement could be hurtful
We can argue it's not open ended.
What's wrong with the statement: A day has 24 hours
It's not open ended
It does not invite multiple perspectives
It's not relevant
You can't follow up on the statement
Racism is already forbidden by law and therefor not relevant.
It's also morraly wrong
It doesn't invite, but exludes multiple perspectives
Follow up on this statement could be hurtful
We can argue it's not open ended.
What's wrong with the statement: FC Utrecht is the best club there is!
It's not open ended
It does not invite multiple perspectives
It's not relevant
You can't follow up on the statement
Racism is already forbidden by law and therefor not relevant.
It's also morraly wrong
It doesn't invite, but exludes multiple perspectives
Follow up on this statement could be hurtful
We can argue it's not open ended.
What's wrong with the statement: You either like reading or you don't
It's not open ended
It does not invite multiple perspectives
It's not relevant
You can't follow up on the statement
Racism is already forbidden by law and therefor not relevant.
It's also morraly wrong
It doesn't invite, but exludes multiple perspectives
Follow up on this statement could be hurtful
We can argue it's not open ended.
What's wrong with the statement: People in the 1600's should pay more respect to the enviroment
It's not open ended
It does not invite multiple perspectives
It's not relevant
You can't follow up on the statement
Racism is already forbidden by law and therefor not relevant.
It's also morraly wrong
It doesn't invite, but exludes multiple perspectives
Follow up on this statement could be hurtful
We can argue it's not open ended.
To conclude:
Make sure the statement is open ended
Make sure it invites different perspectives/opinions
The statement is relevant
You can follow up on the statement
The mistake
Ice cream is nice
You either like ice cream or you hate it
Ice cream should be sold in the netherlands
The only good thing about ice cream is it's tasty
What you need to do
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Now you try!
You will see an incorrect statement. Try to come up with a correct statement that fits the theme of the incorrect one.
Example
Wrong: School uniforms look cool!
Right: School Uniforms should be mandatory in secondary schools in the Netherlands.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Smoking is bad
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Homework is stupid!
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Everyone should go to a football match in their life otherwise you failed in life!
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Now it's up to you! Come up with a good discussion statement!
Pro tips that will help you
Make sure to check the following:
Be specific about the topic. It 's meaning should not be debatable
Use the word "should" in the sentence
Think of a topic you would be comfortable to defend but also deny!
Make sure the statement is open ended
Make sure it invites different perspectives/opinions
The statement is relevant
You can follow up on the statement
Deze slide heeft geen instructies