Island Survival Choices
Island Survival Choices
Open the lesson as a speaking and reasoning task in English. The scenario is that the class is stranded on a deserted island and must agree on five useful items.
Learning goal
I can discuss choices in English, give reasons, and respond to other people's opinions.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Which survival item seems most important to you?
Use this as a quick activation. Invite students to notice which needs come up most: water, food, shelter, safety or communication.
The survival situation
You are stranded on a deserted island.
Your group can choose only five items.
Every choice needs a clear reason.
You must speak in English while deciding.
Keep the task framed as an English speaking lesson: choosing, agreeing, disagreeing and justifying.
The 12 items
a tent
a compass
a first-aid kit
a torch
a radio
20 metres of rope
Items 7–12
Items 1–6
a knife
matches
a phone
10 litres of water
fishing equipment
20 chocolate bars
Students need the exact item list visible so they can refer to the same vocabulary while speaking.
Useful language for choosing
I think we should choose ...
We need ... because ...
This could help us ...
This is more useful than ...
I agree.
I don't agree.
Model full sentences, not one-word answers. Encourage students to compare items, not just name them.
Good reasons are specific
Say how an item helps.
Compare it with another item.
Think about water, food, shelter, safety and communication.
Push students away from vague comments such as 'It is good'. Better examples: 'We chose the knife because it can help us cut rope, prepare food and build shelter.'
Explaining your choices
We chose the rope because ...
We chose the water because ...
We chose the first-aid kit because ...
Our five items work well together because ...
The focus here is production in English: making a choice and justifying it clearly.
Which sentence gives the most specific reason?
It is good for us.
We need it maybe.
It can help us cut and build.
I like this one best.
This checks the idea from the 'Good reasons are specific' slide: students should explain how an item helps, not give a vague opinion.
Complete the useful presentation language
We should choose items with clear reasons. A good reason explains how an item helps us. For example, we need water because it helps us survive. We can also compare one item with another item to make our choice stronger.
The blanks echo the language and reasoning focus from slides 4 to 6.
Explaining what you rejected
We didn't choose the chocolate because ...
We didn't choose the phone because ...
It is less useful than ...
It would not help us enough with survival.
Students often find rejecting easier than choosing. Encourage them to explain the reason, not only state the decision.
Challenging another group
But you can't survive without water!
Why did you choose a phone?
I don't think that is a good idea because ...
What would you use it for?
Keep disagreement polite and language-focused. The aim is to react, challenge and defend choices in English.
Defending your group
We chose it because ...
Our idea was ...
That is true, but ...
We think this item is still important because ...
This slide supports spoken interaction after the presentations, especially giving a counter-argument politely.
Presenting as a group
Start with your final five items.
Give a reason for each one.
Explain one or two items you rejected.
Respond clearly to criticism from other groups.
This is the final language frame for the speaking outcome. Keep the presentation short and reason-based.
Why might a group reject the phone?
Expected elements: students justify one rejected item by comparing usefulness for survival, for example chocolate versus water, or phone versus radio/first-aid kit/rope. Focus on giving a reason in English.
Which reply best defends a choice politely?
You are wrong.
That is true, but we need it.
No, bad idea.
We chose five things.
This checks the debate language from 'Challenging another group' and 'Defending your group'. The best answer acknowledges criticism, then gives a reasoned response.
Complete the debate language
When another group asks why you chose an item, you should defend your idea clearly. You can say, 'That is true, but we think this item is still important.' Then give a clear reason for your choice.
This reinforces the key speaking moves for presentations and challenges: explain, defend and justify.
What speaking skill did you practise best today?
Exit ticket reflection. Encourage short, concrete answers about useful phrases, comparing items, defending choices, or speaking only in English.
What part of this task felt hardest in English?
Exit ticket reflection. Students can mention giving reasons, rejecting items, challenging other groups, or defending choices politely.
Glossary
stranded - unable to leave a place
deserted island - an island with no people living on it
survive - to stay alive
choose - to decide which thing you want
useful - helpful for a purpose
reason - an explanation for why you think something
reject - to decide not to choose something
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Glossary
rope - thick strong cord used for tying or pulling
first-aid kit - basic medical supplies for injuries
fishing equipment - tools used to catch fish
compass - a tool that shows direction
torch - a small portable light
radio - a device for receiving broadcasts
defend - to support your idea with reasons
Deze slide heeft geen instructies