Indeterminate Limits
Indeterminate Limits
Open with the idea that substitution does not always finish a limit. This lesson shows what to do when direct substitution gives an indeterminate form such as 0/0, and how graphs help us interpret one-sided and infinite limits.
Learning goal
I can evaluate indeterminate limits using factoring and rationalisation.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
What words come to mind when you see 0/0 in a limit?
Use this to surface prior ideas and misconceptions such as 'undefined', 'factor', 'simplify', 'does not exist', or 'conjugate'. Briefly note that 0/0 is a signal to do more work, not usually the final answer.
Indeterminate forms
A limit is indeterminate when direct substitution does not give the final answer.
A common form is 0/0.
0/0 does not mean the limit is 0.
It means we must simplify the expression before evaluating the limit.
Stress that 0/0 is a signal, not an answer. Students often think the limit does not exist automatically; clarify that many such limits do exist after simplification.
Using factoring
Factoring helps when substitution gives 0/0 because the numerator and denominator share a common factor.
Steps:
Substitute first and check for 0/0.
Factor the numerator or denominator.
Cancel the common factor.
Evaluate the simpler limit.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Worked example: factoring
Evaluate:
lim x→3 (x² − 9)/(x − 3)
Substitute first:
(3² − 9)/(3 − 3) = 0/0
Factor the numerator:
x² − 9 = (x − 3)(x + 3)
So,
(x² − 9)/(x − 3) = x + 3
Now evaluate:
lim x→3 (x + 3) = 6
Remind students that cancellation is valid only before substituting into the simplified expression, and only when working with x near 3, not at x = 3 itself.
What factoring means on a graph
The original function may be undefined at one point.
After cancelling a factor, the graph follows the same curve nearby.
The missing point is a hole.
The limit depends on values near the point, not at the point.
Connect algebra to the graph: for (x² − 9)/(x − 3), the graph matches y = x + 3 except for a hole at x = 3.
Another factoring example
Evaluate:
lim x→2 (x² − 5x + 6)/(x − 2)
Substitute first:
(4 − 10 + 6)/(2 − 2) = 0/0
Factor the numerator:
x² − 5x + 6 = (x − 2)(x − 3)
Cancel the common factor and evaluate:
lim x→2 (x − 3) = -1
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
After substitution gives 0/0, what should you do next in a factoring limit?
Simplify first
Stop at zero
Square both parts
Read a graph only
Checks the core idea from slides 2–6: 0/0 is indeterminate, so students should factor and simplify rather than treat it as the answer.
Complete the factoring method
When direct substitution gives 0/0, the limit is indeterminate. In a factoring problem, we factor the expression, cancel the common factor, and then evaluate the simpler limit. On the graph, this often appears as a hole at the point.
The blanks echo the language used in the factoring block: indeterminate form, common factor, and hole on the graph.
Why can a limit exist even if there is a hole on the graph?
Expected elements: students should mention that the simplified expression matches the nearby graph, but the original function is undefined at the point, creating a hole. The limit depends on values near the point, not the value at the point.
Why rationalise?
Rationalisation is useful when a square root causes 0/0.
We multiply by the conjugate.
This removes the radical from the numerator or denominator.
Then the expression can often be simplified.
Define the conjugate clearly: for a + b, the conjugate is a − b. In radical expressions such as √(x+1) − 2, the conjugate is √(x+1) + 2.
Rationalisation steps
For limits with radicals:
Substitute first.
If you get 0/0, write the conjugate.
Multiply the expression by that conjugate.
Use (a − b)(a + b) = a² − b².
Simplify, then evaluate the limit.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Worked example: rationalisation
Evaluate:
lim x→3 (√(x + 1) − 2)/(x − 3)
Substitute first:
(√4 − 2)/(3 − 3) = 0/0
Multiply by the conjugate:
(√(x + 1) − 2)/(x − 3) × (√(x + 1) + 2)/(√(x + 1) + 2)
Simplify:
((x + 1) − 4)/((x − 3)(√(x + 1) + 2)) = (x − 3)/((x − 3)(√(x + 1) + 2))
So the limit is:
1/(√(x + 1) + 2) → 1/4
Move carefully through the difference of squares step. Many students need to see exactly why the radical disappears.
Connecting algebra and graphs
A limit describes the value a function approaches.
Simplifying the expression helps us find that value.
The graph shows the same approach visually.
Even if a point is missing, the limit can still exist.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
A second radical example
Evaluate:
lim x→0 (√(x + 4) − 2)/x
Substitute first:
(2 − 2)/0 = 0/0
Multiply by the conjugate:
(√(x + 4) − 2)/x × (√(x + 4) + 2)/(√(x + 4) + 2)
Simplify:
((x + 4) − 4)/(x(√(x + 4) + 2)) = x/(x(√(x + 4) + 2))
So,
lim x→0 1/(√(x + 4) + 2) = 1/4
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Which expression is the conjugate of √(x + 1) − 2?
√(x + 1) − 2
√(x − 1) + 2
√(x + 1) + 2
2 − √(x + 1)
A common confusion is changing the inside of the radical or simply reversing terms. The key idea is changing the sign between the two terms.
Complete the rationalisation steps
For a limit with a radical, start with substitution. If the result is 0/0, multiply by the conjugate. Then use the pattern a² − b² to simplify, remove the radical, and evaluate the limit.
This reinforces the taught sequence from slides 7–11 without adding a new example.
Advanced examples and mixed methods
Some limits need you to choose the best method.
Look for these clues:
Polynomial expression with a common factor → factor
Radical causing 0/0 → rationalise
Already simplified after substitution → evaluate directly
Graph given instead of a formula → read the approach from each side
This slide bridges the two algebraic methods and prepares students to decide rather than follow a labelled example.
Mixed example 1
Evaluate:
lim x→1 (x³ − 1)/(x − 1)
Substitute first:
(1 − 1)/(1 − 1) = 0/0
Factor:
x³ − 1 = (x − 1)(x² + x + 1)
Cancel and evaluate:
lim x→1 (x² + x + 1) = 3
If helpful, remind students of common factoring patterns such as difference of squares and difference of cubes.
Mixed example 2
Evaluate:
lim x→5 (x − 5)/(√x − √5)
Substitute first:
0/0
Multiply by the conjugate of the denominator:
(x − 5)/(√x − √5) × (√x + √5)/(√x + √5)
Simplify:
((x − 5)(√x + √5))/(x − 5) = √x + √5
Now evaluate:
lim x→5 (√x + √5) = 2√5
Point out that sometimes the radical is in the denominator, so rationalising the denominator is the natural move.
Left-hand and right-hand limits
Left-hand limit: approach a value from the left.
Right-hand limit: approach a value from the right.
A two-sided limit exists only if both one-sided limits are equal.
Graphs make this easy to see.
Use notation verbally if needed: x → a− for the left-hand limit and x → a+ for the right-hand limit.
Reading one-sided limits from a graph
When reading a graph:
Follow the curve as x gets close to the target value.
Check the left side and the right side separately.
If both sides approach the same y-value, the limit exists.
If they approach different values, the limit does not exist.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Infinite limits and asymptotes
Sometimes a function grows without bound near a value of x.
Then the limit may be +∞ or −∞.
This behaviour often shows a vertical asymptote.
The graph rises or falls sharply near that x-value.
Clarify that +∞ or −∞ describes behaviour, not a real output value reached by the function at the point.
Interpreting graph behaviour
A graph can show three different cases near a point:
Hole → the limit may exist
Jump → left-hand and right-hand limits are different
Vertical asymptote → the function tends to +∞ or −∞
The picture tells us how the function behaves as x approaches the point.
This is a useful contrast slide: hole links to factoring, jump links to one-sided limits, and vertical asymptote links to infinite limits.
A radical expression gives 0/0 after substitution. Best method?
Direct evaluation
Rationalisation
Factoring only
Graph reading
This checks method choice, which is the key bridge into the mixed-practice section.
Which clue most quickly tells you to use graph reasoning?
A hole
A radical
A graph shown
A polynomial
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
How is a hole different from a jump or an asymptote?
Expected elements: a hole can still have a limit because both sides approach the same y-value; a jump has different left-hand and right-hand limits; a vertical asymptote shows the function increasing or decreasing without bound, often to +∞ or −∞.
Review of methods
Start with direct substitution.
If you get 0/0, do not stop.
Use factoring for common algebraic factors.
Use rationalisation for radicals.
Use graphs to read one-sided limits, jumps, holes, and vertical asymptotes.
This slide prepares students for a later quiz without turning the deck into a quiz itself.
Lesson summary
In this lesson, we focused on limits that cannot be finished by substitution alone. When substitution gives 0/0, we simplify first by factoring or rationalising. We also use graphs to interpret left-hand limits, right-hand limits, infinite limits, and vertical asymptotes.
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
What is one idea from today that now feels clearer?
Encourage students to name one clear takeaway, such as recognising 0/0, choosing factoring or rationalisation, or reading one-sided limits from graphs.
One word for the part of limits you still want to practise
Use the most common responses to decide whether students need more work on factoring, conjugates, one-sided limits, asymptotes, or graph reading.
What helped you understand these limit methods best?
Invite metacognitive reflection on what supported understanding best: worked examples, graphs, step-by-step methods, or comparing methods.
Glossary
limit - the value a function approaches as x gets close to a given number
indeterminate form - a result such as 0/0 that does not give the final value of a limit
direct substitution - replacing x with the target value to test a limit
factor - to rewrite an expression as a product of simpler expressions
rationalise - to remove a radical by multiplying by a conjugate
conjugate - an expression with the sign between two terms changed
one-sided limit - a limit found by approaching from only one side
Deze slide heeft geen instructies
Glossary
left-hand limit - the value approached as x comes from the left of a number
right-hand limit - the value approached as x comes from the right of a number
two-sided limit - a limit that exists when both one-sided limits are equal
infinite limit - a limit where the function increases or decreases without bound
vertical asymptote - a vertical line that the graph approaches but does not reach
hole - a missing point on a graph where the nearby limit may still exist
Deze slide heeft geen instructies