Learning Objective
At the end of the lesson you will be able to explain why Mary I earned the nickname 'Bloody Mary', understand her actions against Protestants, and critically assess historical evidence about her reign.
Learning Objective
At the end of the lesson you will be able to explain why Mary I earned the nickname 'Bloody Mary', understand her actions against Protestants, and critically assess historical evidence about her reign.
What do you already know about Queen Mary I and religious persecution?
Mary I's Persecution of Protestants
Mary I ordered the burning of around 284 Protestants during her five-year reign. On average, nearly one person was executed every five days by being burned at the stake.
Comparing Monarchs: Executions
Other Monarchs
Mary I
Burned 284 Protestants in 5 years, targeting important figures like the Archbishop.
Henry VIII: 81 burned, 70,000+ executed by other methods. Edward VI: 2 burned. Elizabeth I: 5 burned, executed 300 after a rebellion.
Was Mary Unusually Cruel?
Burning heretics was common in 16th-century Europe. Mary’s father-in-law, King of Spain, killed tens of thousands. Most English people were unaffected by the executions.
Mary's Promise and Forgiveness
Mary broke her promise to Lady Jane Grey and had her executed, yet earlier forgave 400 rebels after Wyatt’s rebellion. She also allowed 800 Protestants to flee abroad safely.
How Reliable Is the Evidence?
The key book describing Mary's executions was written by a Protestant who aimed to make her look evil. The stories were often exaggerated, with numbers possibly inflated.
Motives and Influences
Mary showed a dislike of brutality at times but continued executions when she saw they were ineffective in changing faith.
Advisers
Cardinal Pole, a significant influence, allegedly wanted revenge on Protestants after suffering under Edward VI.
Mary's Character
Reflect & Discuss
Was Mary I fairly labelled 'Bloody Mary'? How do the actions of other monarchs and the reliability of sources affect this view?
Write down 3 things you learned in this lesson.
Write down 2 things you want to know more about.
Ask 1 question about something you haven't quite understood yet.