Key defeat examples
2004 Hunting Act: House of Lords opposition
Saw 1911/49 Parliament Acts used for only 7th time since 1911
Numerous Brexit examples – most notable would be Theresa May’s January 2019 parliamentary defeat over her Brexit deal
432 to 202 in favour of rejecting the deal, represented the largest defeat for a sitting government in modern history (since 1924)
What did this lead to for Theresa?
Key defeat examples
2004 Hunting Act: House of Lords opposition
Saw 1911/49 Parliament Acts used for only 7th time since 1911
Numerous Brexit examples – most notable would be Theresa May’s January 2019 parliamentary defeat over her Brexit deal
432 to 202 in favour of rejecting the deal, represented the largest defeat for a sitting government in modern history (since 1924)
What did this lead to for Theresa?
Today’s Aims & Intentions
Today’s Aim = To assess the effectiveness of various forms of Parliamentary scrutiny over the Executive
Intentions – By the end of this session, you will be able to:
Outline one strength & one limitation of Backbenchers’ ability to hold the government to account
Outline two strengths & two flaws of ‘Questioning Ministers’ in Parliament
Assess how effectively Parliament can hold the executive to account
Reach a conclusion over which House is more effective in holding the government to account
Backbenchers
‘Lobby Fodder’, who vote and do as party says?
Concept of ‘Parliamentary Privilege’
MPs being free to speak without fear of prosecution for slander within Parliament’s walls
Independence: Since 2007, backbenchers have become more independent than in previous decades –backbenchers often negotiate with governments to get amendments before voting
Select Committees emphasise backbench independence – membership no longer controlled by whips so more likely to embarrass government?
Forms of Scrutiny
https://www.theguardian.com/media/2011/may/23/ryan-giggs-mp-injunction
Urgent Questions
If an urgent or important matter arises which an MP believes requires an immediate answer from a government minister, they may apply to ask an urgent question
Speaker considers applications – if granted, receive an oral answer from minister on the same day
Former Speaker John Bercow was a major champion of backbench rights – granted over 150 urgent questions from 2009-2014
Forms of Scrutiny
Tory backbench strife…
As you watch, make notes:
What problems did Liz Truss have with backbenchers?
What about Theresa May?
Tory MP visibly furious over party chaos: 'the damage they have done is extraordinary' - YouTube
The Brexit Mistakes That Led to Theresa May's Resignation (HBO)
Famous backbench rebellions
Thatcher, 1986: Shops Bill, providing Sunday trading, defeated by 14 votes
Blair, 2005: 90-day terrorist suspect detention rejected with 49 rebels, 322 vs 291
Cameron, 2013: Action in Syria, lost by 13 votes
May, 2018-19: EU Withdrawal Agreement (3 Defeats on whole deal – 15th Jan, 12th March & 29th March 2019)
Johnson, 2019: Boris Johnson removing the whip from 21 MP’s who voted against Brexit plan
Truss, 2022: Ousted by backbench pressure
Brexit showdown: Who were Tory rebels who defied Boris Johnson? - BBC News
Backbench Business Committee
Established in 2010
Chair must be an opposition member, with membership again reflecting composition of Commons (8 members)
Backbenchers allowed to choose topics to debate for 35 days of the year (approx. one day a week) – this committee manages this
Topics can be chosen by individual backbenchers, or via e-petitions signed by the public, with decisions on what is discussed chosen by the committee
Gives backbenchers more say and power over Parliament’s debates
Forms of Scrutiny
Limits to Backbench powers
Whips:
Entice them with giving positive reports on them to PMs ahead of governments reshuffles (‘carrots’)
OR…
Threatening to reveal embarrassing information about MPs to the media and scuppering promotions (‘sticks’)
Whipping System: Three-line whip – refusal could see expulsion
Resources: Backbenchers have limited research and admin staff compared to government
Majority: Government with large Commons majority means government dominance usually – backbenchers tend to accept government’s plans & vote with them, even if they may disagree
Forms of Scrutiny
Backbench support depends on…
Ambition: If they think PM is there for the long-term, ambitious MPs will vote with PM to please them as they appoint Cabinet & government
Keeping their Seat: An MP in a more marginal seat will be more likely to support a popular PM - enhance chances of re-election
Supports the PM’s Agenda: Vote with PM simply because they like them & agree with their policies
Dislikes the PM’s Agenda: Equally, backbenchers who don’t like the PM/ policies are less likely to vote for them
Forms of Scrutiny
Votes of no confidence
Can dismiss the government of the day and call an election
Only needs a simple majority to pass
Only proposed in House of Commons
Last loss: James Callaghan in 1979 (311-310)
Recent examples: May (Jan 2019) and Johnson (July 2022 – after he resigned), but both survived
Forms of Scrutiny
Activities of The Opposition
Ability to scrutinise the executive is limited by factors beyond its control
Size & Unity of governing party
Length of time government has been in power
But well-coordinated opposition can still influence popularity & power of a government
Blair opposition of 1994-1997 presenting Major’s weaknesses effectively, and simultaneously showed themselves as a great alternative
Cameron opposition (2005-2010) underlined divisions in Labour Party, with Blair vs Brown tensions & exploiting crises’ like the 2008 financial crash
Forms of Scrutiny
What is Questioning?
Formally asking members of government questions within Parliament’s chambers
Allows MPs or Peers to question government ministers on decisions, policies & actions they/their departments have made
Prime minister’s questions
Wednesdays at 12 noon in House of Commons once a week
Gives the Leader of the Opposition, and then backbench MPs, a chance to question the Prime Minister on current issues, policy areas of debate, or raise issues & concerns to government on the behalf of their constituents
Conduct chaired by the Speaker
Effective Example? How can we argue this is effective scrutiny? What impact did it have?
'Gone! Gone! Gone!': Keir Starmer v Liz Truss (2022)
Questioning & PMQs = Effective scrutiny?
Strengths
PMQs forces PM to be well-informed about policy agenda & wider news
Leader of the opposition can apply pressure & expose any major government mistakes
PMQs is significant & unique globally, plus can lead to success… Corbyn overturning premium rate number to call Universal Credit
Urgent Questions: Demand attendance of relevant minister to answer questions and face criticism
Flaws
Too many questions from ‘friendly’ government backbenchers
PMQS = Political & Media theatre rather than proper scrutiny? Theatrics are a media distraction from more complex, less ‘sexy’ issues
PMQs is about point-scoring: ‘Punch and Judy’ with MPs cheering and shouting in a childish manner – leads to public apathy & dislike of politics/politicians
Reform inbound?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckgyleldl27o