Employment lesson 1.pptx


Employment Law – Lesson 1



By Jayne Harding LL.B(Hons) LLM DipEd QTLS

1 / 9
volgende
Slide 1: Slide
newEditor

In deze les zitten 9 slides, met tekstslides.

Dit is niet oké

Onderdelen in deze les


Employment Law – Lesson 1



By Jayne Harding LL.B(Hons) LLM DipEd QTLS


Learning objectives:


  • Explain the difference between a contract OF services and contract FOR services. 

  • Identify the relevant tests for determining if a worker is an 'employee', 'self-employed' or 'independent contractor'.

  • Analyse relevant case law in employment law to evaluate the ratio decidendi for the Court's decision in employment law cases.

  • Application of employment law cases to new and recent case studies.

Contract OF Service – vs – Contract for services.

  • What is the key difference between a contract OF service and a contract FOR services?


  • Contract OF Service:

  • Employee – Employer relationship.

  • Master and servant relationship.  


  • Yewens v Noakes (1880) 6 QBD.

  • Control Test – The level of control which an employer can exercise over their employees.





Activity 1 – Read the case of Ready Mixed Concrete (15 minutes).

  • Identify the tests applied in the obiter by Lord Justice McKenna;

  • Be ready to feedback the answers to the class!






Contract For Services.

  • A contract FOR services relates to a person who is likely to be self-employed or freelance.  


  • Courts & Tribunals will consider the following factors and tests when considering if an employee is self-employed or freelance.

  • Freedom to 'pick and choose' working hours, the employer has limited control over their working hours.

  • Tax and National Insurance contributions. - Paying your own tax and insurance if an indication of self- employment.

  • Own equipment and transport – own car and paying for petrol is an indication of self-employment.

  • Pension contributions – responsible for making own pension contributions.



Tests for worker status;

  • The Integration test/organisation test.

  • The Courts/Tribunals will examine how integrated the employees are in the everyday work and practices of the business.


  • Stevenson, Jordan & Harrison Ltd v Macdonald & Evans Ltd.

  • Lord Denning decided that even in the event that the employer doesn't have control over the employee as long as they are integrated into the business organisation and working as part of the team they are considered to be an employee.


  • Whittaker v MPNI (1976).

  • The Court decided that the artist's performed other integral features and therefore was an employee.

Multiple tests

  • Often referred to as the economic reality test.

  • This test is more relied upon where it considers several factors in order to determine whether there is an employer and employee relationship. 


    Ready-Mixed Concrete (South East) v MPNI

  • The driver of the company must buy their own vehicle and paint it in the company's own colours. The workers must wear the company's uniform and be available for work when required. Their salary was paid according to the mileage their travelled in relation to their work performed for the company.

  • The workers were held to be self-employed rather than employees, they were operating at their own financial risk.

Activity 2 – Read the case of UBER v ASlam (2021).

  • Answer the following questions after reading the FULL Judgement.


  • How did the Supreme Court determine whether the workers were "employees" or "independent contractors".

  • Explain what is the ratio decidendi (Court's reasoning for making the decision), what factors if any did they take into account?

  • Identify the relevant employment tests (if any) that the Court used to apply to the decision in this case?

  • Did the Supreme Court agree/disagree with the decision in Autoclenz Ltd v Belcher [2011]?

  • Did the Supreme Court set any new precedents (if any) what were they?



Plenary

  • Name 3 tests used by the Courts/Tribunals to determine worker status?


  • Differentiate between a contract OF service and a contract FOR services?


  • Identify what other factors that Courts and Tribunals look at when determining the status of a worker?